Connect to share and comment

Flanked by foreign dignitaries, Karzai announces a runoff

Two months to the day after Afghanistan’s badly flawed presidential elections, the stalemate is over.

Afghan President Hamid Karzai speaks during a news conference in Kabul, Oct. 20, 2009. Karzai claimed to welcome the runoff election against his main rival on Nov. 7. (Ahmad Masood/Reuters)

KABUL, Afghanistan — President Hamid Karzai bowed to international pressure on Tuesday and announced that Afghanistan would hold a runoff election on Nov. 7.

The voting, which comes after weeks of mounting allegations of voter fraud, will pit Karzai against the second-place finisher and former foreign secretary, Abdullah Abdullah.

Flanked by the cream of the international diplomatic corps and a foreign dignitary or two, the Afghan president beamed as he hailed the decision as a victory for the democratic process.

“We welcome the decision as legitimate, legal and according to the constitution,” said Karzai. “It will strengthen the process of democratization. It will be an historic period we are waiting to go through.”

The decision  the Afghan president was referring to was a rather grudging press release issued by the Independent Election Commission just minutes before Karzai’s press conference.

“The Independent Election Commission … has determined that his Excellency Hamid Karzai has received 49.67 percent of the total valid votes and is recognized as the leading candidate … Although the IEC has some reservations regarding the decisions of the Electoral Complaints Commission … considering time constraints, the imminent arrival of winter and existence of problems in the country, announces that the second round of the elections will be held on 7th November of this year.”

The Electoral Complaints Commission (ECC) yesterday ordered the IEC to disqualify some 1.3 million votes, which brought Karzai under the 50-percent-plus-one threshold needed to avoid a runoff. Up until the ECC decision, Karzai was claiming a first-round victory with some 55 percent of the vote. According to the ECC report, Abdullah received 31 percent of the vote.

Standing shoulder-to-shoulder with the Afghan president were U.S. Senator John Kerry, U.N. Special Representative Kai Eide, and the ambassadors of the United States, the United Kingdom and France.

It was a ringing endorsement for a president who up until a few hours before the event was seen as intransigent and obstructionist in the face of overwhelming evidence that the victory he claimed had been the result of fraud. He had staunchly resisted calls for a runoff, necessitating frantic international diplomacy by Kerry, among others.

“[The president] has shown statesmanship by deciding to move forward, by embracing the constitution and the rule of law,” said Kerry, warmly shaking hands with Karzai in front of the cameras. “[This] will allow the government to lead with legitimacy.”

Kerry acknowledged that he had spent many hours with the Afghan president in recent days, and that the “deliberations were lengthy and sometimes difficult.”

But in the end, he said, “the Afghan people have taken a significant step towards a better future.”

Curiously absent from the speeches of the principals was any reference to the reason the election process has been so long and contentious: the massive fraud that the ECC determined had taken place throughout the country, particularly in the south.

Indeed, Karzai went out of his way to question those findings and to challenge the ECC, hinting at future retribution for those who questioned the first-round results.

“The Afghan elections have been defamed,” he said. “There were 1.3 million votes called ‘suspicious,’ most of which were in the south. The people’s votes are not blamed. We must deeply investigate why the people’s votes were disrespected. But this is not the time for investigations. This is the time for stability and national unity.”