
Brazilian President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva in a photo taken when he was running for president in 2002. In this photo, taken Sept. 9, 2002, he is embraced by an Afro-Brazilian woman during a campaign rally in the city of Salvador. (Paulo Whitaker/Reuters)
For Which It Stands: Brazil
Colorblind melting pot or racially divided society? Either way, Afro-Brazilian leaders welcome Obama.
MARAGOJIPE, Brazil — Walking through this colonial-era fishing town of 44,000 across the Bay of All Saints from the city of Salvador, your average U.S. resident would come to a quick demographic conclusion: Most people here are black.
The townspeople, however, beg to differ. Only 13 percent of the population declared themselves “negro,” or black, in the 2000 census. Another 62 percent said they were “pardo,” a response that translates as “brown” or “dark,” but which some black leaders in Bahia — generally considered the most culturally African state of Brazil — interpret as “Who, me? Black? No way.” Still others whom Americans might consider black declare themselves “white.”
If that sounds complicated, welcome to Brazil, which is either a) the color-blind melting pot where blacks have been equal under the law far longer than they have been in the United States, or b) the last country to outlaw slavery, where Afro-Brazilians make up nearly half the population and are devastatingly impoverished, poorly educated and have only the sparsest presence in the elite ranks of CEOs, television news announcers and high-level politicians. And, of course, there has never been a black president.
Black leaders hope that Barack Obama’s election in a country many Brazilians consider more racist than their own will force a hard self-examination.

“The United States has always served as a model for the world,” said Marcelino Gomes de Jesus, who runs a nonprofit cultural center in the nearby town of Cachoeira. “I don’t think that whites will change their image of blacks in Brazil now. But what will change is blacks’ image of themselves.”
Here in Maragojipe, it took until 2004 for the town to elect a black mayor, Silvio Jose Santana Santos, a broad-shouldered 37-year-old with a penchant for red clothing, the color of his Workers Party. And even then, his campaign slogan, “A star is shining” was turned against him by an opponent, who in a speech noted that, “Black stars don’t shine.”
The mayor, who goes by the political name Silvio Ataliba, distinguished the history of Jim Crow laws in the United States from race relations in Brazil. “They say racism doesn’t exist,” he said. “But here’s what happened: we traded slave quarters for favelas (slums).
“Racism is camouflaged. People call you ‘neguinho’ [a diminutive of ‘negro’] and they think they’re being affectionate. They call you ‘black with a white soul.’ We still haven’t accomplished in our society what black Americans have in theirs, and I’m not just talking about Obama’s election,” Ataliba said.
Though black leaders in Brazil often looked to figures like Martin Luther King and Rosa Parks as models, the movement in Brazil was dampened from the mid-1960s to mid-1980s by the military dictatorship. But there has been progress since, the mayor noted. Among the signs in the last decade: increasing roles for black actors and controversial racial quotas for admission to Brazil’s prestigious public universities. He notes that he has heard — but is not sure — that Obama was a beneficiary of quotas in the United States.
On a recent evening in Cachoeira, Gomes de Jesus, older and more skeptical than Ataliba, was watching a news report on Obama in his run-down but invitingly warm center, the Casa Paulo Dias Adorno. He is a priest of Candomble, the religion of African origin influential in this part of the country.
“Blacks in the United States had the opportunity to grow socially, culturally and politically,” Gomes de Jesus said. “So much so that today white Americans elected a black man president. That indicates that whites in the United States came to the conclusion that if you’re capable, you can have power, whether you’re white or not.”
Most Brazilian whites, he believes, do not feel the same way. He suspects that “white Brazilians find it absurd that a black man is president of the United States.”
Meanwhile, de Jesus said, Afro-Brazilians are also to blame. “Blacks here are afraid of asserting their blackness,” he said. “They’ll say that they don’t have any racial problems at all, because they don’t consider themselves black.”
Down the river and across the bay is Salvador, the city of nearly three million famous for its carnival and usually considered the epicenter of Afro-Brazilian culture. There, business leader Clarindo Silva, a slender 63-year-old man with a snowy-white goatee, was so excited about the U.S. election that he had bilingual “Obama — The dream of Luther King and all of us” T-shirts made up for sale at Cantina da Lua, his restaurant in the city’s historic Pelourinho neighborhood.
“I think the election of Obama is a very strong message for the world,” Silva said. “What changes there, changes here. It’s a great example for humanity.”
"He suspects that 'white Brazilians find it absurd that a black man is president of the United States.'”
Mr. Gomes de Jesus's suspicion sounds preposterous to anyone who does not live in the Northeast, Brazil's most backward region, dominated by a parasitic elite since colonial times. While his generalization might well apply to that local elite, it does not reflect how "white Brazilians" feel. Living and working in São Paulo, the country's largest city, and having contact with people of all walks of life, I have not heard one single person express anything other than positive feelings about the election of the first black president of the US.
If on the one hand Brazil has a long way to go towards curbing social inequality, of which black people are the major victims because they are the majority of the population, on the other hand the adoption of a confrontational rhetoric directly imported from American movements clearly does not help advance the goal of equality, racial and otherwise. Although it is obviously misleading to call it a "colorblind melting pot", Brazil is fundamentally different from the US in racial terms in that the overwhelming majority of Brazilian "whites" are in fact mixed-race. Therefore, Brazil should find its own way of dealing with this serious issue rather than simply trying solutions used in a country with a history of official segregation and hatred on the part of both blacks and whites.
Mr. Andre Gallo makes two points to differentiate Brazil's experience of racism from that of the US: one, that "social inequality" is the cause of black people's problems, which in the above context I take to mean that Brazil is an unequal society where many/most are poor, and since most people are black, most of the poor are black. Two, those who would be considered white in the US are often of mixed-race in Brazil.
I would argue that these two points show more similarities than differences, however.
If one were to examine the economic status of blacks vs. whites in Brazil according to a US perspective of black/white, I would strongly suspect that a far higher percentage of blacks as a group than whites as a group are poor. This is similar to the US. (Note on US white/black categorization: Mr. Obama is generally referred to as black even though his mother is white, which really makes him classically mixed race)
When talking about white versus black in a the US or Brazil, it's the appearance that counts; nobody asks for a genealogical table to check the race/nationality of one's great-grandparents. If one looks white, people will treat a person as such and vice-versa. In other words, perhaps most people in Brazil who would be considered white are of mixed-race, but that is a mere technicality: to appear white is to be white, and to appear black or brown is to be black or brown; actual ancestry is a detail.
Recent on Brazil :
Sign of the times
Seth Kugel - Brazil - October 16, 2009 09:31 ET
Sao Paulo’s clever new no-smoking symbol is so ubiquitous, it sometimes seems like it’s following you.
The "little country that could" didn't
Mark Starr - Sports - October 14, 2009 20:50 ET
In a World Cup drama, tiny Uruguay tried — but failed — to put Argentina out of its misery.
A World of Trouble: Is the nightmare over?
Thomas Mucha - Commerce - October 14, 2009 13:35 ET
With signs of economic recovery finally emerging, here's where things stand in 20 countries around the world.
2016 Olympics: Three funerals and a party
Thomas Mucha - Commerce - October 4, 2009 09:13 ET
Rio rocks. Chicago, Madrid and Tokyo mope.
The 2016 Olympics: The betting odds
Mark Starr - Sports - October 4, 2009 09:12 ET
President Obama is headed to Copenhagen. Will it matter?
Should internet campaign ads be against the law?
Seth Kugel - Brazil - September 17, 2009 16:55 ET
Brazil is trying to change laws that limit political speech. But it still wants to forbid anonymous blogging.
The only Ethiopian in Brazil
Seth Kugel - Brazil - September 13, 2009 09:12 ET
Alienated and out of hair gel, one woman struggles to hold on to her heritage.
The Ritz of movie theaters
Seth Kugel - Brazil - September 9, 2009 08:06 ET
Welcome to Sao Paulo's ultra-luxe theater, where wine is served and the popcorn topping is truffle-infused olive oil.
Need an Advil in Brazil? Not so fast.
Seth Kugel - Brazil - August 28, 2009 09:15 ET
Brazil wants to adult-proof its pharmacies.
Peering into the future with scientific arson
Stephan Faris - Global Green - August 16, 2009 08:02 ET
Scientists are setting fires in the Amazon to figure out how encroaching agriculture and climate change will affect forests.
Meet the economic gangsters
Mark Scheffler - Commerce - August 12, 2009 09:03 ET
Economic gangsters come in all shapes and sizes — they're Asian dictators and Somali pirates.
Will "civilized" Brazilians obey a new smoking ban?
Seth Kugel - Brazil - August 6, 2009 19:17 ET
A new law in Brazil's biggest city bans smoking in public places. Will it be obeyed?
Brazilian Senate scandals: a guide
Seth Kugel - Brazil - August 4, 2009 12:04 ET
Get caught in a scandal in Brazil and you might lose your job. You'll almost never go to jail.
A tale of two Lulas
Seth Kugel - Brazil - August 3, 2009 09:01 ET
International rock star or illiterate hick? You decide.
More than a tourist destination
Anil Mundra - Argentina - August 3, 2009 08:59 ET
Trafficked persons flow across the triple border of Argentina, Brazil and Paraguay at the Iguazu falls.
Full Frame: Africans in the Americas
Sebastian Belaustegui - Worldview - July 31, 2009 08:27 ET
Full Frame: African rhythm to a Latin American beat
Sebastian Belaustegui - Worldview - July 28, 2009 08:35 ET
The slave trade dispersed Africans throughout the Americas. A photographic journey through the remaining Afro-American cultures.
Taiwan says goodbye to World Games 2009
Jonathan Adams - China and its neighbors - July 27, 2009 09:19 ET
VIDEO: How did your favorite korfballer do?
The sporting death
Mark Starr - Sports - July 24, 2009 13:10 ET
The murders of Steve McNair and Arturo Gatti stun the sports world, and underscore the complexity of the word "hero."
Watch GlobalPost videos:
Reporter's Notebook
There's no real need to write a story here. The headline says it all. But because convention must be followed, here goes: On Wednesday, Anvisa, the...Read more >
There are some people you look at and think: this guy has a story to tell. That’s the impression I got from the bushily grey-bearded guy in the...Read more >
I’m now back in Novo Aripuana (pictured), where the perfectly decent Hotel Tio Ze does not have perfectly decent beds for back pain sufferers....Read more >
Featured: Special Projects
After the Fall:
20 years since the Berlin Wall came down
Life, Death and the Taliban:
Videos and stories
Study Abroad:
Students report from the road
Living in the Shadows:
An intimate look at China's migrant workers
A World of Trouble:
The global economy in 20 hotspots
Global Blogs:








Comments:
2 Comments.
Login or Register to post comments