People are seen at Copacabana beach in Rio de Janeiro July 22, 2007. (Daniel Munoz/Reuters)

Romance or something else?

In Rio, the relationships between male tourists and local women are not always as simple as they appear.

By Seth Kugel - GlobalPost
Published: January 27, 2009 14:27 ET
Updated: February 20, 2009 16:20 ET

RIO DE JANEIRO — This is one of the world’s most popular tourist destinations for many reasons: the iconic urban beaches, the bafflingly dramatic landscape, the bursting-at-the-seams music scene.

The sex.

Like it or not (and most locals don’t like it), many men come to Rio with one thing on their minds. But are they there to hire prostitutes, as female friends back home might suspect, or simply to strut their masculinity in a sexually freer society, as they themselves like to think?

While there are plenty of genuine love stories here between brasileiras and turistas, and plenty more cold fee-for-service transactions, it’s often not a simple question of you-paid-or-you-didn’t. There are many gradations on the romance-to-prostitution continuum.

Take, for example, a scene that played out on the edge of Copacabana Beach last year. Two black Brazilian women, likely in their late teens, sit in bikinis near roasted-red tourists at a coconut-water-and-beer kiosk. My snap judgment: they’re certainly poor, and probably prostitutes.

Suddenly, one gets a cell phone call, shrieks in delight, and runs off gabbing. I strike up a conversation with her friend, whose name was Natalia, telling her I was a reporter interested in Brazilian women’s relationships with tourists.

Natalia thought that was quite a coincidence, because her pal just happened to be talking to a friend that was off to visit her Belgian boyfriend — in Belgium. The two had met during his trip to Rio months ago and maintained a relationship over several more of his visits. Now he had flown her to Europe, marriage offer pending, to see if she liked it. Apparently, she loved it: she was getting breakfast in bed, overcoming her fear of riding a horse for the first time, and being treated like “a queen” by the man’s family.

Prostitute suddenly seemed like the wrong word. But so did innocent schoolgirl.

Natalia, who also had dated many tourists, explained how the system works: Direct payment per sexual encounter is not common. Dinners, drinks, and gifts are.“I like to combine utility with pleasure,” she said. “The material aspect is part of it. But it is pleasant to be with a man who likes me, who treats me well.” The ultimate prize, she said, is “to go away to another place, to have a good life.” Belgium, apparently, qualifies.

Later in my trip, I met Mylla Reys having a late night hamburger at a Copacabana snack bar. She was 18, and had come to Rio at 16 from the central Brazilian city of Goiania, escaping a bad marriage and chasing an acting dream. She, too, said she dated tourists. A week after she got to Rio, she said, she “fell in love” with an American musician in town on a gig.

“I didn’t have any desire to meet a foreigner, none,” she said. But after meeting friends at the beach, she spotted a dreamy blond-haired, blue-eyed guy. She couldn’t say anything because she didn’t speak English, but she made sure he caught her staring. “He was very cold,” she said. Cultural translation: He didn’t come over to sweet-talk her.

A male friend of hers suggested she go up to him and kiss him, but she refused. “In Rio, things happen like that,” she said. “In my city, no.” But friends broke the ice, and they all went out to eat. On the way back to the beach she dared to grab his hand. Still cold. Finally, she playfully pulled off his cap, and he pulled her in for a smooch.

“It was the most beautiful kiss of my life,” she said. They sat on the beach for hours, talking. Sort of. “He spoke and he spoke and I didn’t understand anything,” she said.

The next night, they went out dancing at Rio Scenarium, a popular nightclub, and she stayed over at his hotel.

Communication — the verbal kind — continued to be a problem until the next day, when they went to an internet cafe to use Google Translate.

“I never imagined I would find a person like you here in Rio de Janeiro,” she remembers him writing.

They were together for a week, communicated by internet for a few months after that, and then he disappeared. Mylla was devastated, even asking me — six months after they had last spoken — what I thought had gone wrong. I gave a dishonest answer.

Though she missed him, she had met, dated and slept with other tourists since (and even acted in a few plays). They sometimes gave her money and gifts, she said, but never directly for sex.

“I don’t ask,” she said. “It seems cold. I don’t think that the fact that you are a tourist means you should give me money. You’re not my husband! The only difference is you’re from another country.”

Most recently, she had been dating a Brazilian. So had she finally decided to kick the dead-end tourist habit and develop a lasting relationship? No, she said: she liked him because he had a nice car, expensive cologne, and plenty of money. 

Comments:

3 Comments.

Login or Register to post comments

Posted by linacar13 on January 28, 2009 22:22 ET

This is an interesting piece but as a reporter you dangerously distorted a serious subject. I think as a reporter you took the wrong angle to the whole situation. First of all, where in the story do you interview a male tourist and ask them for their intentions in having a "Brazilian romance?" The part that distorted the problem the most is that in the end of the article you make the women seem as if they are the ones at fault for falling into a trap of wanting to have money and cars, intentionally implying that these women don't want any kind of lasting relationship. Do you talk about the exploitation of women, sex trafficking, the sex trafficking of children that happens? How Western men intentionally go to Brazil to do this and take advantage of the prostitution? What about the roots of the problem, why are woman forced to go into prostitution in Brazil?

I think you are look at this issue through the lens of a Western male, not giving the whole story. You even stated it yourself in the beginning of the article, you were interested in a "Brazilian women’s relationships with tourists." However, you do not address the other side of the coin: a tourist's relationship with a Brazilian woman.

You don't explain to the reader why for a Brazilian woman it would be better to go live in Belgium then it would be to live in Brazil?

I read the way that you chose to write this story, but you seemed to only ask very surface questions. If you wanted to hear these women's voices then you would have dug deeper. For example, why do they feel the necessity to be in these types of relationships?

Posted by fwdesouza on February 23, 2009 19:37 ET

Seth does not distort "the problem," as you call it. He simply provides a different perspective than most readers are used to. I am tired of reading about the immorality and debauchery that is the tourist sex scene in Brazil and plenty of other places (which it is; I don't condone it). However, Seth gives his readers a different perspective that is seldom explored. It is not the reporter's job to explore and excruciatingly pick apart every side of a story. Instead, the best stories deeply analyze one aspect or perspective of an issue. He does his job well.

Posted by igneousquill on March 23, 2009 10:10 ET

Excellent article. My wife is Brazilian (we didn't meet in Rio and she wasn't fishing for a foreign husband, by the way) and I lived in Brazil for nearly three years. I don't know that I'd label this a "problem" as someone else put it in a comment, but it is definitely an ambigious issue. Not really prostitution, but certainly romance motivated by more that love at first sight. Honestly, it makes sense from a practical perspective for a Brazilian woman from difficult circumstances to pursue a relationship with a relatively more affluent foreigner. She can have more than one reason for being interested in someone, and would be a fool not to consider a man's economic status among other factors. Then again, love should come into the picture somewhere, at some point in time.

Recent on Brazil :

Sign of the times

Seth Kugel - Brazil - October 16, 2009 09:31 ET

Sao Paulo’s clever new no-smoking symbol is so ubiquitous, it sometimes seems like it’s following you.

The "little country that could" didn't

Mark Starr - Sports - October 14, 2009 20:50 ET

In a World Cup drama, tiny Uruguay tried — but failed — to put Argentina out of its misery.

A World of Trouble: Is the nightmare over?

Thomas Mucha - Commerce - October 14, 2009 13:35 ET

With signs of economic recovery finally emerging, here's where things stand in 20 countries around the world.

2016 Olympics: Three funerals and a party

Thomas Mucha - Commerce - October 4, 2009 09:13 ET

Rio rocks. Chicago, Madrid and Tokyo mope.

The 2016 Olympics: The betting odds

Mark Starr - Sports - October 4, 2009 09:12 ET

President Obama is headed to Copenhagen. Will it matter?

Should internet campaign ads be against the law?

Seth Kugel - Brazil - September 17, 2009 16:55 ET

Brazil is trying to change laws that limit political speech. But it still wants to forbid anonymous blogging.

The only Ethiopian in Brazil

Seth Kugel - Brazil - September 13, 2009 09:12 ET

Alienated and out of hair gel, one woman struggles to hold on to her heritage.

The Ritz of movie theaters

Seth Kugel - Brazil - September 9, 2009 08:06 ET

Welcome to Sao Paulo's ultra-luxe theater, where wine is served and the popcorn topping is truffle-infused olive oil.

Need an Advil in Brazil? Not so fast.

Seth Kugel - Brazil - August 28, 2009 09:15 ET

Brazil wants to adult-proof its pharmacies.

Peering into the future with scientific arson

Stephan Faris - Global Green - August 16, 2009 08:02 ET

Scientists are setting fires in the Amazon to figure out how encroaching agriculture and climate change will affect forests.

Meet the economic gangsters

Mark Scheffler - Commerce - August 12, 2009 09:03 ET

Economic gangsters come in all shapes and sizes — they're Asian dictators and Somali pirates.

Will "civilized" Brazilians obey a new smoking ban?

Seth Kugel - Brazil - August 6, 2009 19:17 ET

A new law in Brazil's biggest city bans smoking in public places. Will it be obeyed?

Brazilian Senate scandals: a guide

Seth Kugel - Brazil - August 4, 2009 12:04 ET

Get caught in a scandal in Brazil and you might lose your job. You'll almost never go to jail.

A tale of two Lulas

Seth Kugel - Brazil - August 3, 2009 09:01 ET

International rock star or illiterate hick? You decide.

More than a tourist destination

Anil Mundra - Argentina - August 3, 2009 08:59 ET

Trafficked persons flow across the triple border of Argentina, Brazil and Paraguay at the Iguazu falls.

Full Frame: Africans in the Americas

Sebastian Belaustegui - Worldview - July 31, 2009 08:27 ET

Full Frame: African rhythm to a Latin American beat

Sebastian Belaustegui - Worldview - July 28, 2009 08:35 ET

The slave trade dispersed Africans throughout the Americas. A photographic journey through the remaining Afro-American cultures.

Taiwan says goodbye to World Games 2009

Jonathan Adams - China and its neighbors - July 27, 2009 09:19 ET

VIDEO: How did your favorite korfballer do?

The sporting death

Mark Starr - Sports - July 24, 2009 13:10 ET

The murders of Steve McNair and Arturo Gatti stun the sports world, and underscore the complexity of the word "hero."