
A girl braves a H1N1 influenza vaccination shot and a regular flu shot in Vancouver, British Columbia, Oct. 26, 2009. Last week, as people from high-risk groups lined up around city blocks to receive their swine flu vaccines, players from the Calgary Flames and the Toronto Maple Leafs jumped to the front of the line, causing widespread outrage. (Andy Clark/Reuters)
Welcome to Canada, where the little guy loses
Professional hockey players cut in front of old ladies waiting for flu shots, and a Chinatown grocer gets charged for catching a thief.
TORONTO, Canada — Professional hockey players are used to being transformed from heroes to bums depending on their performance in a game. Rarely, however, do they attract the fury of even those who care little about the sport.
It happened in Canada last week when news broke that players on two teams — the Calgary Flames and the Toronto Maple Leafs — jumped to the front of the line to be vaccinated against swine flu.
The news came as lineups reserved for high-risk groups stretched around city blocks. That meant that highly paid athletes had jumped ahead of pregnant women, children below the age of 6, and people with chronic illnesses, many of whom had waited up to seven hours at immunization clinics. The preferential treatment also came as some clinics were forced to shut down because they ran out of vaccine. (Also last week, in Ukraine, which is gripped by a swine flu pandemic and in the throes of election leadup, H1N1 became fodder for the biggest political football match to date.)
As outrage grew in Canada, the players and coaches for the most part ducked the media. But a few tried to justify the move.
John Mitchell, who plays center for the Leafs, insisted that pro athletes are at a higher risk of contracting bugs.
“We go from city to city and rink to rink,” Mitchell told reporters. “There's people that might be an avid fan who doesn't want to miss a game even though he's feeling a little sick. They come to the rink. You never know what will happen from there. We have every bit of a chance of catching it as everybody else, maybe a little bit more.”
By the time Mitchell voiced his defense, a pattern had emerged. It was learned that the board of governors of seven Toronto hospitals — often stacked with the well-heeled — had also jumped the long queues and received the H1N1 vaccine. And, a private Toronto clinic that serves executives of corporations who each pay $2,300 to become clients had received 3,000 doses of the scarce vaccine.
Similar debate erupted south of the border when Wall Street heavy weights like Goldman Sachs and Citigroup were given doses of swine flu vaccine. A Goldman Sachs spokesperson insisted the shots would be given only to high-risk employees.
In Canada, provincial health ministers in Alberta and Ontario have vowed investigations. Two health bureaucrats in Alberta were fired for apparently having approved the preferential treatment given the Calgary Flames. Still, the incidents confirmed what every school child knows: The big wheels get the grease.
Said Sharleen Stewart, president of a union that represents Ontario health care workers: “What we are seeing evokes scenes from the Titanic, the privileged pushing to the front and leaving vulnerable women and children to a chilling fate.”
In Canada Hockey Stars get preferential treatment when it comes to swine flu vaccination. In the US - it's employees of Goldman Sachs.
Wow what a bunch of tough men. Taking vaccinations when pregnant women and children can't get them.
I am annoyed by all the idiots who hold a grudge against the NHL players and teams for getting the shots. When the Flames arranged to have the shots they didn't know there was a shortage. For the sake of efficiency they arranged to have the whole team (and their families) inoculated privately. Can you imagine the chaos if the Calgary Flames show up at a public clinic and wait for 6 hours. In any case the bureaucrat who authorized it lost his job and the team apologized. Don't begrudge the teams for running their business efficiently and treating their employees and families as we all wish the government health care system would treat us.
My issue is with the idiotic, manipulative media that tries to generate fear or anger or feelings of injustice all too often at the expense of journalistic integrity.
Hey Sandro, stop feeding the media fires. Firstly you are about a week behind on this story, additionally, the Flames have already spoken out on this subject, see below:
-------------------------------------
Calgary Flames H1N1 medical protocol
Tuesday, 03.11.2009 / 2:06 PM / News
calgaryflames.com
--------------
The Calgary Flames issued the following statement today in regards to H1N1 medical protocol:
Recently Flames fans and Calgarians will have heard and read information concerning our medical protocol for the prevention of H1N1 amongst our players.
For clarity, our organization and our medical staff felt that our players should receive the vaccination given the risks associated with frequent physical contact, extreme exertion and onerous domestic and cross border travel.
Last week our team physicians worked with Alberta Health Services and assessed the risks on our team and the potential commotion and intrusion that sending the team to one of the locations would cause.
Consequently, on Friday our players were vaccinated at an off-site clinic within the public system and under the direction of Alberta Health Services.
The prudence of this approach has and will come under close scrutiny due to the controversial nature of the flu pandemic and the recently-announced change to the vaccination protocol and move to a full priority-based distribution system.
Our players did not seek to either avoid line-ups or get special attention.
They followed the direction of our medical staff and our organization.
We sought counsel and guidance on this matter and determined it appropriate given the facts available at the time.
We accept full responsibility for our actions and decisions.
Recent on Canada :
Special Report
Thomas Mucha - Commerce - January 28, 2010 17:24 ET
20 correspondents, 20 countries and a world of pain. Meet the ground truth of the global economic crisis.
Canadians no longer swoon for Obama
Sandro Contenta - Worldview - January 19, 2010 19:41 ET
Analysis: One year on, Canadians are much like their American counterparts: They like the man more than his policies.
To Transport Canada, even books are suspect
Sandro Contenta - Canada - January 14, 2010 06:46 ET
Canadians have followed the US lead on all things security, but do they know when to say when?
Canada no longer a haven for war resisters
Sandro Contenta - Canada - January 12, 2010 14:02 ET
Prime Minister Stephen Harper is determined to send back the some 200 American asylum-seekers who have fled the Iraq war.
Canadian decision riles South Africans
Erin Conway-Smith - South Africa - December 30, 2009 15:37 ET
Black and white South Africans outraged at Canadian decision to grant man refugee status because he is white.
Canadian democracy, like a bull moose head-butting a train
Sandro Contenta - Canada - December 30, 2009 07:08 ET
The train, in this case, is Prime Minister Stephen Harper and his Conservative government.
Quebec’s ski helmet debate slips
Raffy Boudjikanian - Canada - December 26, 2009 10:13 ET
After Natasha Richardson's fatal ski accident in Mont-Tremblant last March, it looked like a mandatory helmet law might happen.
Canada: a climate change loser
Sandro Contenta - Canada - December 17, 2009 09:42 ET
Harper's government is content to follow the U.S. on climate change policy.
Tough on crime, but not on rifles
Sandro Contenta - Canada - December 10, 2009 06:45 ET
Canada's Conservative government pays tribute to the Montreal Massacre, but ponders loosening gun regulations.
Cigarette smuggling rises in Canada
Sandro Contenta - Canada - December 4, 2009 06:39 ET
Sandro Contenta has seen firsthand how smugglers slip smokes across the Canadian border.
Securing America’s northern front
Colin Woodard - Canada - November 27, 2009 13:14 ET
Washington’s War on Terror is disrupting sleepy communities on the Canadian border, where some can’t buy gasoline without a passport.
Shattering Canada's collective myths
Sandro Contenta - Canada - November 26, 2009 10:00 ET
Peacekeepers give way to warriors in Afghanistan, and a nation open to immigration becomes one that bans permanent residents.
Where have all the salmon gone?
Sandro Contenta - Canada - November 20, 2009 17:32 ET
The Humber River was teeming with this year's run. But salmon populations are declining elsewhere in Canada, leading many to question whether that will always be the case.
Welcome to Canada, where the little guy loses
Sandro Contenta - Canada - November 11, 2009 08:49 ET
Professional hockey players cut in front of old ladies waiting for flu shots, and a Chinatown grocer gets charged for catching a thief.
Why Stephen Harper prefers US news
Sandro Contenta - Canada - November 2, 2009 20:08 ET
Questions over Canada’s role in the Afghanistan war and unflattering polls have the prime minister eyeing the exits.
Exploiting the motion of the ocean
Colin Woodard - Canada - October 30, 2009 09:35 ET
Energy companies are trying to turn eastern Canada's coast into the Saudi Arabia of tidal power. Critics fear for the fisheries.
Montrealers have no problem walking the walk
Raffy Boudjikanian - Canada - October 26, 2009 07:58 ET
In Canada's second-largest city, jaywalking pedestrians feel that they always have the right of way.
Canadian health care — it's their right
Sandro Contenta - Canada - October 21, 2009 10:19 ET
In contrast to the US, where health care is a commodity, Canada has, so far, treated it like a human right.
Hockey-crazed Canada can't keep the puck on its own turf
Sandro Contenta - Canada - October 16, 2009 14:15 ET
How a billionaire's thwarted effort to bring the Phoenix Coyotes to Ontario reinforces the troubling trend of NHL teams migrating south.
Watch GlobalPost videos:
Reporter's Notebook
Prime Minister Stephen Harper is ending this year the way he ended the last one — by suspending Parliament to get out of a political...Read more >
Montreal has long been home to Canada’s most notorious biker gangs and mobsters. Its recent history is smeared with gangland slayings. But few...Read more >
My column this week was on how even though cigarette smuggling slowed down in Canada in the late 1990s, it's come back with a vengeance over the last...Read more >
Featured: Special Projects
Oceans:
Assessing their health
After the Fall:
20 years since the Berlin Wall came down
Life, Death and the Taliban:
Videos and stories
Study Abroad:
Students report from the road
Living in the Shadows:
An intimate look at China's migrant workers
A World of Trouble:
The global economy in 20 hotspots






Comments:
4 Comments.
Login or Register to post comments