Uighur people shop in the main market of Hetian, in the region of Xinjiang, April 5, 2008. (Nir Elias/Reuters)

Confused about the Xinjiang riots? Follow the money.

DiggThis

The unrest is less about Islam and more about economics.

By Josh Chin - GlobalPost
Published: July 11, 2009 11:26 ET

SAN FRANCISCO — For Kasim Tuman, a Uighur activist living in California, the explanation for the long-simmering resentment between his people and the Han Chinese that boiled over into deadly ethnic riots in northwest China last week is a matter of two numbers: 6 and 40.

The first is the percentage population of Han Chinese in Xinjiang, the Uighurs’ native province, prior to the establishment of the People’s Republic of China. The second is that percentage today.

“The influx of immigrant Han Chinese is so large that Uighurs have become a minority in their own land,” said Tuman, the West Coast coordinator the Uighur American Association.

Beijing’s explanation for last week’s violence is equally simple: It was the work of overseas Uighurs like Tuman — terrorist organizers, the government says, who manipulated their fellow Muslims back home to embark on a bloody rampage.

As columns of Chinese troops maintain a semblance of calm in Urumqi, the provincial capital where at least 156 died and hundreds more were injured in the deadliest episode of ethnic violence in modern Chinese history, attention both in China and abroad has turned to the question of why.

The riots appeared to have grown out of protests over the killing of Uighurs by a mob of Han Chinese factory workers in Guangdong province angry about the rumored rape of two Han Chinese women in the factory. But as with the Rodney King trial and 1992 Los Angeles race riots, the Guangdong incident was a catalyst for the violence, not an explanation for the violence in and of itself.

Tension between Han Chinese and mostly Muslim Uighurs dates back centuries. In recent years, the struggle has come to be seen by some as an issue of religion. This is thanks in large part to the government’s classification of independence-minded Uighurs as terrorists (a shift in rhetoric linked to China’s acquiescence in the George W. Bush’s War on Terror). But observations by scholars, the reactions of regular Han Chinese and the experiences of Uighurs themselves suggest the conflict is less about Islam and more about economics.

The Urumqi riots produced an explosion of indignation inside China itself. As with riots in Tibet in March of 2008, much of the commentary focused on preferential economic policies directed at the region.

“How many other countries treat minorities as favorably as China does?” one YouTube user wrote in Chinese under a video depicting the riots. “Why are some people still unsatisfied? They don’t understand gratitude.”

Since the start of its “Go West” campaign in the year 2000, Beijing has invested tens of billions in Xinjiang in an effort to develop its rich stores of oil (China’s second-largest), uranium, gold and other minerals. Such investment is described in Chinese state media as a boon to Uighurs and other minorities in Xinjiang — a sort of ethnic minority stimulus plan. While the region’s GDP growth has hovered in the teens, however, the practical benefits to Xinjiang natives have been meager.

Comments:

4 Comments.

Login or Register to post comments

Posted by beargib on July 12, 2009 02:56 ET

Good points -- and the historical context is especially important. Two elements worth exploring further: the "go west" campaign may have been articulated somewhere publicly in 2000, but as the story points out, the government has pushed Han Chinese west for generations. The most recent "push" began after 1989. It was not welcomed by either Uighur or the Han who had to move (might want to look at who moved and the incentives involved). One other question is whether there IS much oil in Xinjiang. And gee, what companies fought so hard for the contracts to find and develop the fields north and south of Urumqi? Chinese oil companies didn't have the technology to find much of anything in 1990... Like the headline says: follow the money. And all of a sudden the plot gets pretty complicated.

Posted by Willy on July 13, 2009 11:35 ET

I think Tuman shall realize, as a result of cold war, Uighur is not the largest ethnic group in Xinjiang. they can not take any advantage in referendum or suffrage. if they do want to establish "Eastern Turkey". it can only get support in a small patch of southern Xinjiang, while other ethnic groups, such as Kazak and Mongolian, have no aspiration for independence. To establish a independent country among barrent desert, the beneficiary can only be those politician.
i think he had better expect China can become a democracy country. the citizen's sense of belonging base on people living in this land can respect each other, all kinds of race can live togher in harmony instead of base on common race,history and xenophobia as present.

Posted by citiarc on July 13, 2009 11:46 ET

Still biased! you should separate the chinese government and chinese people, including Hans and Uighurs. governments exploitate all of its people, without distinction of their ethnicity. The Uighurs repeated starts racist attacks on Han chinese, in response to the government! That is truely unfair to the Han immigrants who must face hostility and pressure on both sides.

Posted by Josh Chin on July 19, 2009 15:26 ET

@beargib, @Willy, and @citiarc, many thanks for your comments. It's always a pleasure to get feedback from readers, and all of you make valid points.

@Willy, part of my interview with Mr. Tuman (left out of the article for space reasons) speaks directly to the issue you raise. Here's the quote from my notebook:

"A referendum on independence in Xinjiang wouldn't work because we [Uyghurs] are already a minority there. If there was a vote in Xinjiang, what would happen? We would definitely lose. So the only real hope is for all of China to become a democracy. But I don't think that's going to happen in the near future."

So the question remains fraught, even for relatively strident pro-independence activists like Mr. Tuman...

Thanks again for reading GlobalPost's China coverage and taking the time to express your opinions. I sincerely hope I'll continue to see you on the site going forward.

Recent on China and its neighbors:

Opinion: China contributes to Dalai Lama’s mystique

HDS Greenway - Worldview - February 8, 2010 11:05 ET

The more the Chinese threaten and scold, the more they promote the Dalai Lama's importance around the world.

Adventure travel: The Great Himalaya Trail?

Jason Overdorf - India - February 4, 2010 07:11 ET

Why walk Everest, K2, and other mountain giants? Because they are there.

Opinion: How did China get double-digit economic growth?

Joel Brinkley - Worldview - February 3, 2010 11:17 ET

By dealing with some of the world's most repugnant regimes. Iran is just the latest on a long, long list.

Analysis: Taiwan says hello to arms

Jonathan Adams - China and its neighbors - February 2, 2010 14:56 ET

Taiwan asked for weapons from the US years ago, and most on the island back the deal.

Analysis: China's tougher than before

Kathleen E. McLaughlin - China and its neighbors - February 2, 2010 13:12 ET

Washington is hardening its stance, China is rising to the occasion and there's likely trouble down the line.

Special Report

Thomas Mucha - Commerce - January 28, 2010 17:24 ET

20 correspondents, 20 countries and a world of pain. Meet the ground truth of the global economic crisis.

Mac Rumor Alert: What Apple's "iTablet" could mean for Asia

Jonathan Adams - China and its neighbors - January 27, 2010 09:48 ET

Here's the latest chatter about the supply chain of the coming Apple gadget — if it really exists.

Kidnapping in China

Colum Murphy - China and its neighbors - January 27, 2010 06:40 ET

As the number of child kidnappings in Shenzhen grows, so too does distrust between parents and police.

China v. Google: Beijing fights back

Kathleen E. McLaughlin - China and its neighbors - January 25, 2010 20:14 ET

The Chinese government takes a swing at Hillary Clinton. How bad can this get?

Taiwan rocks: They're loud. They're angry. They hate the Chinese government.

Jonathan Adams - China and its neighbors - January 24, 2010 08:25 ET

Meet Chthonic, Taiwan's premier metal act. Don't expect to see them in China anytime soon.

The Fantastic Five: Best photos of the week

News Desk - General - January 23, 2010 09:16 ET

Best pictures include a Madrid storefront, aid delivery in Haiti and an aboriginal Australian Elvis impersonator.

Police shut down Mr. Gay China competition in Beijing

Dinah Gardner - China and its neighbors - January 15, 2010 12:59 ET

Restrictions on homosexuality have relaxed in recent years, but state still keeps a watchful eye.

Unesco, China and a Uighur mystery

Kathleen E. McLaughlin - China and its neighbors - January 13, 2010 06:39 ET

What are the Chinese up to in the Old City of Kashgar, the Uighur "Jerusalem"?

Economic worries in Indonesia? Blame the Chinese.

Peter Gelling - Indonesia - January 10, 2010 07:56 ET

A new regional trade deal raises tensions between two rising economic powers.

Can China save General Motors?

Thomas Mucha - Commerce - January 9, 2010 10:06 ET

Seven thousand miles from Detroit, GM builds a great wall of Buicks.

The Whiskey Diaries: Scotland in Taiwan

Jonathan Adams - China and its neighbors - January 5, 2010 06:36 ET

Can Taiwan produce a world-class tipple?

Taiwan's over-the-top pleasure dens

Jonathan Adams - China and its neighbors - January 4, 2010 06:44 ET

Love Motel 2.0

Jonathan Adams - China and its neighbors - January 4, 2010 06:42 ET

Taiwan's love motels are stepping up their game with outrageous themes, web movie marketing and extra privacy.

Holiday shopping: The next big thing in Taiwan?

Jonathan Adams - China and its neighbors - December 23, 2009 06:59 ET

A look behind the booming business of e-books. It's a page turner.