Did a US company hire a Colombian paramilitary group?

A lawsuit alleges that Drummond Company paid a right-wing paramilitary for protection.

By Nadja Drost - GlobalPost
Published: May 30, 2009 10:47 ET
Updated: May 31, 2009 11:06 ET
Page 2 of 2

“If Drummond hadn't financed the [paramilitary] groups in the zone, they wouldn't have strengthened the paramilitary, and perhaps they wouldn't have been able to cause all the damage that they did,” Claudia Barcero said by phone from Valledupar in northern Colombia.

In 2000, Barcero’s husband was sent along with six colleagues from the attorney general’s office to investigate and exhume a body that had “disappeared” in a community that was under the control of the paramilitary group Drummond is accused of financing. The forensic team never returned. Years later, paramilitary confessions pointed to the AUC as their killers.

Today, Barcero — who is one of over 220 plaintiffs in the Conrad and Scherer case — said she and other families are “looking for the remains of our relatives and for justice.”

The lawsuit does not refer to the plaintiffs’ names in order to protect their identities. The legal team in Colombia said many were nervous or reluctant to provide testimony out of fear of retaliation from the paramilitary which, though officially demobilized, still has active units in the region.

Such circumstances are one of the many challenges legal teams encounter in trying to bring hard evidence against companies long suspected of doing business with illegal armed groups. “In these cases, the legal principle is pretty clear,” said Beth Stephens, an international law expert at University of Rutgers-Camden in New Jersey. “To prove what happened is not easy.”

In Colombia, that may change. In 2003, the AUC started demobilizing under a government amnesty program (its Northern Block demobilized in 2006) that granted immunity to foot soldiers and reduced sentences for high-ranking paramilitary commanders who confessed their crimes.

Those confessions could be the linchpin that implicates Colombian and foreign companies in supporting paramilitary death squads. Now, in public hearings and from their jail cells, paramilitary leaders are providing key testimony about the money and directives exchanged between companies and illegal militia groups.

In March, Conrad and Scherer re-submitted the case it had lost in an Alabama court, based on new evidence provided by jailed paramilitary leaders who said the order to kill the three union leaders came from Drummond leadership.

Testimony from top AUC commanders was also crucial in a lawsuit filed against the Dole Food Company in California last month on behalf of the families of 57 Colombians the suit claims were killed by paramilitary members hired by Dole.

There are several cases, also filed under the Alien Tort Claims Act, pending on behalf of victims against Chiquita. The banana giant settled for a $25 million fine to the U.S. Justice Department after admitting in 2007 it had paid over $1.7 million to the paramilitary — the company said the payment was extortion money to protect its employees.

But for many of the plaintiffs in this week’s case, there is no possible explanation for Drummond’s alleged support to the paramilitary that would exclude the company from responsibility in the deaths of their family members. As Barcero said, “If they were involved in one way or another, they have to pay.”

Editor's note: This story was updated to correct the spelling of a name on second reference.

 More GlobalPost dispatches on Colombia:

Slideshow: Bastardilla's Bogota

Becoming an accordion king

Drug traffickers move underwater


View Larger Map

Comments:

1 Comments.

Login or Register to post comments

Posted by Mora on May 30, 2009 21:39 ET

You couldn't get better than a "senior" paralegal to comment for your story, Nadja? Worse still, you didn't ask her how she gathered her 'testimony,' did you? Did you ask her if she dangled big lawsuit settlement bucks in front of them? Or do people just love to tell foreign "senior" paralegals all about the killers threatening them in their neighborhood? Is it really that simple, Nadja? Or did she dangle big gringo tort bucks - which may well have affected their stories? I guess you weren't curious and didn't ask.

Meanwhile, which is it, the leftwing terrorists making terror attacks or the so-called 'rightwing' AUC? Graf two says it's the AUC and graf three says it's the leftists. Guess you weren't too curious about that either.

More importantly, define "rightwing" as you do with AUC terrorists. Some have trotskyite backgrounds, tell me how that makes them rightwing. Most respectable reports even by leftwing groups for Congress do not call AUC "rightwing" because the fact is, they aren't rightwing, they are just doper thugs of no known ideology. But it makes a nice neat symmetry for you to insist that AUC is rightwing just because the they fight FARC IS leftwing. Kind of assuages your own conscience for being leftwing and having to answer to that, doesn't it? They all do it, right? Wars are complicated, not symmetrical. Your simpleton version just doesn't have anything to do with reality.

Meanwhile, Ms. ace hot investigative reporter, some basic housekeeping: Magdalena and Cesar are DEPARTMENTS, not provinces of Colombia. You can get that kind of information from any Colombian (skip the gringo "senior" paralegals, ok) or else Wikipedia. You also spell an "anonymous" plaintiff's name two different ways - Barcero and Borcero, so which is it?

Did you ask the "senior" paralegal why her law firm kept suing Drummong over and over again, despite losing in courts? Did you ask who was paying for this? Was it a gringo union? Cuz I think it was a gringo union. But you didn't ask.

Methinks you aren't really interested in the craft of reporting, the art of writing , or the hard work of determining facts. You have zero skepticism and gladly allow yourself to be spoonfed by tort-happy lawyers looking for a big payday. This article signals you are an activist who'd like to be considered an objective reporter. You're going to have to try harder to fool us.

Recent on Colombia:

War-zone tourism

John Otis - Colombia - November 8, 2009 09:45 ET

It's a national park “where the rainbow becomes a river.” And it's nearly empty.

Soccer team's murder leaves villagers scared

Charlie Devereux - Venezuela - November 4, 2009 06:55 ET

The murder of an amateur soccer team has heightened tensions between Colombia and Venezuela.

Colombia's rebel turncoats

John Otis - Colombia - October 29, 2009 07:12 ET

A government propaganda blitz urges FARC rebels to give up the fight. It seems to be working.

In the jungle with the Colombian army

John Otis - Colombia - October 29, 2009 07:06 ET

A reporter accompanies a Colombian army mission and observes why winning the war remains so difficult.

Angel, or FARC in disguise?

Nadja Drost - Colombia - October 10, 2009 11:49 ET

Colombian Senator Piedad Cordoba evokes strong reactions from supporters and detractors alike.

Colombia's spy scandal

John Otis - Colombia - October 1, 2009 05:54 ET

The intelligence agency has been spying on Colombians — but most don't care if it means they're safer from guerrillas.

Putting a community, and its land, underwater

Nadja Drost - Colombia - September 23, 2009 06:05 ET

Peasants are angry about being pushed off their land for a hydroelectric project whose energy might not even go to Colombians.

Is South America in an arms race?

Nadja Drost - Colombia - September 20, 2009 06:27 ET

Major arms purchases stoke fears of flaring regional tensions on an increasingly militarized continent.

Essay: How to deal with kidnappings

John Otis - Worldview - September 18, 2009 06:02 ET

As the Taliban takes more high-profile hostages, there are lessons to be learned from Colombia's war with the FARC.

Digging up the dead

John Otis - Colombia - September 9, 2009 05:45 ET

Colombia is excavating its civil war dead for the first time — sometimes by going into active war zones.

A Colombian's quest

John Otis - Colombia - September 6, 2009 16:15 ET

Video: The father of a soldier held prisoner symbolically crucified himself to call attention to the plight of Colombia’s hostages.

Anti-Chavez and anti-Uribe protesters face off

Nadja Drost - Colombia - September 6, 2009 14:59 ET

Social networking organizes international protests against the Venezuelan president.

New waves of displacement

Charlie Devereux - Venezuela - September 4, 2009 15:18 ET

Colombia's offensive against armed groups has increased the flow of refugees across the Venezuela border.

Run off their land

John Otis - Colombia - September 4, 2009 05:49 ET

Farmers displaced by war and ignored by politicians are searching for a new life in Bogota's slums.

Bribery accusations in case against Chevron

John Otis - Colombia - September 2, 2009 11:32 ET

In case over Amazon cleanup, Chevron releases videotapes it says implicate the judge in a bribery scheme.

Return of the dictators?

John Otis - Colombia - September 2, 2009 08:14 ET

Colombia's Alvaro Uribe is the latest in a string of Latin American leaders to push for more time in office.

A new stage for drug deals and turf wars

Nadja Drost - The Americas - August 29, 2009 17:00 ET

Panama, once one of Latin America's safest countries, is now home to gangs and drug violence.

A jailed teacher and a prison library

Nadja Drost - Colombia - August 25, 2009 09:19 ET

Colombia's penitentiaries are increasingly filled with political prisoners accused of belonging to insurgent groups.

Cockfighting: cruelty or culture?

John Otis - Colombia - August 21, 2009 12:37 ET