Could I please have my painting back?

Restitution of property looted by the Nazis takes on new urgency.

By Bruce I. Konviser - GlobalPost
Published: July 1, 2009 06:13 ET
Updated: July 7, 2009 09:23 ET
Page 2 of 2

So, for now, her father's art work continues to languish out of sight in the museum's storage room. No one from the museum could be reached for comment.

There are thousands more cases — each with their own variations, but broadly similar to that of Friedman-Morris. She, in fact, is luckier than many because her father's diaries gave her clues as to where to look. Others don't know where to begin their search.

A declaration passed at the conference, and signed by 46 participating states, calls on signatories to, among things, expedite the opening of archives to help victims and their heirs locate property; pass laws to ease the bureaucratic transfer of property; and make funds available to compensate for lost property; and help those who are struggling economically.

They're all the “right things." Except that it's all non-binding, which means that there is no legal force behind it, just like the first such conference in 1998. The focus then was more on communal property, and the resulting “Washington Principles” sought to cajole governments to return stolen property without the force of law. As a result, most countries ignored their commitments.

Ironically, the result has been that Germany and Austria have paid out billions of dollars in compensation, but their East European neighbors, who view themselves as Nazi victims, have generally refused to make amends. No one questions that Germany's neighbors were also victims, but Holocaust restitution advocates point out that much of the looted property and art is believed to be in government hands today.

Stuart Eizenstat, who is leading the U.S. delegation, estimates that the Nazis plundered $17 billion — which would be worth $170 billion today — worth of movable and immovable property from Jews, Gypsies and other ethnic or social groups they targeted.

“The Holocaust was not only the greatest genocide in history, it was also the greatest theft in history,” Eizenstat said in an interview. “We're also focusing on social needs of 170,000 survivors, a third of which are at or below the poverty line. It's unacceptable that people who suffered so much in their early lives should now have to live in deprivation and choose between food and medicine.”

He also lauded the proposal to establish the Terezin Institute, to be located at the site of the former concentration camp, which he said would be tasked with developing restitution and compensation guidelines for regional countries.

One advocate for the Holocaust victims made it clear that he would very much prefer a binding declaration to a non-binding one. But he insisted the conference is still important “because it forces people to dance,” he said, explaining that the conference creates social pressure for action.

Holocaust survivor and Nobel Peace Laureate Elie Wiesel said in an interview with GlobalPost that the time to act is now.

“Restitution is absolutely urgent now because it's 65 years after the event, which as I said during the conference, I found scandalous — that it took so long to deal with this problem,” he said. “I hope that now that at least many needy survivors will benefit from it and that all artwork will be returned, and at least, at least that justice should prevail.”

Clarification: The Friedman family changed the spelling of their surname in 1960, dropping a second 'n' at the end.

Read more on World War II legacies:

Argentina's anti-Semitic past

Poland: Remembering suffering, without downplaying guilt

A 'skinny kid' returns to Normandy, year after year

Comments:

1 Comments.

Login or Register to post comments

Posted by david wayne osedach on July 3, 2009 16:34 ET

The burden of proof rests entirely on the heir. We're 60 or 70 years later. How can anyone come up with that kind of proof?

Recent on Czech Republic :

The European School: a microcosm of EU integration

William Echikson - Worldview - November 11, 2009 19:32 ET

Czech and Slovak students don't dwell on their countries' communist past.

Opinion: The day after the Wall fell

Michael Moran - Worldview - November 9, 2009 17:55 ET

The fears of Germany and its neighbors in 1989 have largely been resolved by 2009.

Constitutional debate erupts as early elections are canceled

Bruce I. Konviser - Czech Republic - October 18, 2009 10:15 ET

The Czech Republic hashes out exactly what the judiciary can and can't do in its still fledgling democracy.

It ain't over till Vaclav Klaus sings

Teri Schultz - European Union - October 9, 2009 19:34 ET

The Irish have given their all-important "aye" to the Lisbon Treaty, but another obstacle exists: the anti-EU Czech president.

G20 Pittsburgh: They meet again

Michael Goldfarb - Worldview - September 22, 2009 06:13 ET

Opinion: The world does not hold its breath.

Opinion: Obama's move was not appeasement

HDS Greenway - Worldview - September 18, 2009 16:51 ET

The only purpose for a missile defense shield in Eastern Europe was to provoke Russia.

Starbucks is a-brewing in Prague

Bruce I. Konviser - Czech Republic - September 11, 2009 08:13 ET

The Seattle-based coffee chain may be pulling back in the US, but it's all over Central Europe.

The decline of America and Poland's special relationship

Jan Cienski - Poland - September 10, 2009 05:34 ET

In the Obama era, both the US and Poland turn their focus elsewhere.

Writing the history books

Bruce I. Konviser - Czech Republic - August 16, 2009 08:52 ET

Is the Institute for the Study of Totalitarian Regimes producing legitimate scholarship or pursuing a political agenda?

'Europe's Detroit' skids

Jan Cienski - Europe - August 13, 2009 18:09 ET

In the economic downturn, the wheels have come off of Slovakia's auto-dependent economy.

The Czech love affair with beer

Bruce I. Konviser - Czech Republic - July 31, 2009 08:17 ET

The "Institute of Beer" is trying to prove that Czech beer is the most "drinkable" in the world.

Ugly blob or cultural treasure?

Bruce I. Konviser - Czech Republic - July 24, 2009 08:16 ET

The battle over Prague's proposed funky-looking library.

Could I please have my painting back?

Bruce I. Konviser - Czech Republic - July 7, 2009 09:23 ET

Restitution of property looted by the Nazis takes on new urgency.

Czechs pass the keg to Swedes

Teri Schultz - European Union - July 2, 2009 11:53 ET

Sweden acknowledges that its six months at the EU's helm could be "difficult."

A stock bet in Poland

Jan Cienski - Poland - June 15, 2009 12:11 ET

Can the Warsaw Stock Exchange be a regional leader? Only if it breaks free from the government, proponents say.

Czech MPs not so special

Bruce I. Konviser - Czech Republic - June 13, 2009 13:25 ET

Attempt to transform the military police into a Special Op unit fails.

Czechs fear rise of the right in EU vote

Bruce I. Konviser - Europe - June 6, 2009 11:05 ET

Extremists parties are unlikely to win seats, but they could win state subsidies.

Egg attacks signal a dark turn of events

Bruce I. Konviser - Czech Republic - May 30, 2009 08:04 ET

An assault on a Czech politician has sparked a level of violent protest not seen since 1989.

Missile defense suffers setbacks

Bruce I. Konviser - Czech Republic - May 21, 2009 07:20 ET

Czech government delays treaty vote as Iran tests a missile.