Connect to share and comment

Indo-Pak Watch: Mr Singh's problems

India's PM pays a political price for a happy moment.

India's Prime Minister Manmohan Singh attends the national communal harmony awards ceremony in New Delhi, Aug. 12, 2009. (B Mathur/Reuters)

NEW DELHI — They met, they shook hands and they penned a joint statement at the sidelines of the Non-Aligned Movement summit meeting in Sharm el Sheik last month. For anyone watching, such camaraderie between the prime ministers of India and Pakistan seemed a welcome break from the tension following the November 2008 Mumbai attacks launched by Pakistan-based militants.

In the aftermath of that attack few Indians — in government or among the public — felt warmly towards Pakistan.

But even eight months later, the offering of an olive branch by India's prime minister, Manmohan Singh, to Pakistan caused a maelstrom in all sorts of circles in the Indian capital. The prime minister’s offense? Not just shaking hands with his Pakistani counterpart, Yousaf Raza Gilani, but releasing a joint statement that riled up New Delhi for its casual mention of two issues.

First, action on terrorism, the statement read, should not be linked to dialogue. This just after a high court in the Pakistan released Hafiz Saeed, believed to be the mastermind of the Mumbai attacks.

Second, the text contained a veiled reference to Indian intelligence activity in Pakistan’s restive province of Balochistan, which critics argue is equal to an admission of involvement in Pakistan’s internal affairs. But when Parliament convened, a senior member of the main opposition party declared that, “all the waters of Neptune will not wash away the shame of Sharm el Sheik.” It’s hard to know where this reaction leaves the Indo-Pak relationship, especially since India and Pakistan seem to see things through polar lenses. Still, a prime minister’s sincere efforts to confront the conflict, seen here as a blunder most unkind, may in fact do some good.

“He wants peace, we appreciate that,” said Retd. Gen. Ved Malik, former chief of Indian armed forces. “But we are not talking about two individuals here. We see no change in the jihadi infrastructure in Pakistan.”

Security analysts agree. “How much can you go on ensuring your good faith, only to have Pakistan come back with some idiotic adventure, something that serves their internal dynamic but doesn’t do anything to advance peace in the region?” asked Bharat Karnad of the Center for Policy Research, a think tank in New Delhi.

Terror aside, much of the debate in India has revolved around Balochistan, where a separatist movement has long been underway. Pakistan has repeatedly alleged that India is destabilizing it by assisting separatists, a claim that has been ignored next to the long charge sheet against Pakistan.

http://www.globalpost.com/dispatch/india/090812/indo-pak-watch-the-problems-mr-singh