Connect to share and comment

David Petraeus, one of the most lauded figures in recent US military history, resigned Nov. 9 from his post as CIA director over an extramarital affair. GlobalPost brings you the latest on the evolving scandal.

Egypt obama election
An Egyptian woman buys a newspaper featuring a front page picture of US President Barack Obama. (Khaled Desouki/AFP/Getty Images)
United States

The Petraeus affair: heard around the world

From a street market in Pakistan to a newsstand in Peru, people across the globe voice their minds over America's new scandal.

BOSTON, Mass. — Some commend David Petraeus for resigning, others scratch their heads over the fuss his affair has made, but America's usual observers — the rest of the world — have plenty to say about the unfolding scandal involving the ex-CIA chief and a four-star general, a biographer and an apparently email-happy socialite.

From a market in Pakistan to a newsstand in Peru, people on the street have offered GlobalPost varied opinions about the Petraeus affair.

Here's what they had to say.

 

PAKISTAN

KARACHI — Since David Petraeus was appointed director of the Central Intelligence Agency, which oversees the drone program that's firmly opposed by Pakistan's military, there has been little love lost between the country and the retired general.

On the streets of Karachi, residents interviewed by GlobalPost this week expressed a mix of suspicion of the "real" reason for Petraeus' resignation, and admiration for his honesty.

In Karachi's historic Saddar district, two vegetable vendors spoke about the lessons Petraeus could teach Pakistan's leaders.

"For a man to admit that he was wrong, that he did something so horrible to his family is pretty impressive," said the first. "I can't believe that he would just go to the president and say 'I made a mistake' and ask for forgiveness."

The other nodded cautiously. "In any case," he mused, "self accountability is important. In Pakistan, if an MP [member of parliament] made a mistake, like for example, faking a college degree, you would never see them take responsibility for their actions. I think he's a brave man."

The two men had learned from an Urdu-language BBC News broadcast that Petraeus resigned his leadership of the CIA last week after knowledge of his extramarital affair became public. Both felt the affair wasn't a big enough reason for resignation, and talk in the market revolved around ulterior motives.

"We're hopeful that this means less drones," said Faiza Mumtaz, a student of political science at Karachi University who was shopping at the market. "Although it is the United States, and we're never sure that they're telling the world the truth."

Other shoppers agreed. "I think that what's more likely is that Petraeus and Obama had a disagreement on what they wanted out of the CIA. I mean, it's suspicious that the news about his affair came so close after Obama's election. Who knows what this is about."

The CIA's use of drone strikes has been extremely unpopular in Pakistan. Citizens believe they threaten Pakistan's sovereignty, and many activists protesting against the strikes view Obama's re-election with trepidation.

"I think that the one thing that we all know," said Hakim Amir, an employee of a wealthy Pakistani family who was purchasing meat at the market, "is that Obama is a huge fan of drone strikes. If someone were to challenge that, they'd probably get the boot."

Amir, who was born in Pakistan's northwest, blames the US president for robbing him of a family; his brother was killed in a drone strike last year.

In his first four years in office, Obama authorized nearly 300 drone strikes in Pakistan, more than six times the number during the George W. Bush administration, according to the New America Foundation policy institute. Since 2004, a total of 337 US drone strikes in Pakistan have killed between 1,908 and 3,225 people.

But one of the vegetable vendors thought perhaps Petraeus's resignation really was personal. "Maybe he was a just a man who fell in love," says the first. "I'd like to see a photograph of his lady."

The second one has a slightly different take. "The fact is that the CIA works in many other countries that are not Pakistan" he reasons. "Maybe he and Obama disagreed about one of those countries. Here, we don't think the drone strikes will stop."

Mariya Karimjee
 

EGYPT

CAIRO — Many Egyptians say the scandalized CIA chief’s decision to resign is the right one.

“He is very respectable for resigning,” said Bahaa, a 20-year-old arts student in Cairo. He said he vaguely remembers hearing about the scandal. “It’s important that someone like that has a good reputation.”

Egypt’s army gets over a billion dollars in US military aid — and weapons and equipment — each year. But unaffected by direct US military occupations like in Iraq or Afghanistan, Egyptians largely view the “Petraeus affair,” which has now broadened to include Gen. John Allen in Afghanistan, through their own local political lens.

More from GlobalPost: 50 Shades of Khaki — the John Allen-Jill Kelly emails

Discussing military and intelligence affairs, which are clouded in layers of secrecy, is largely taboo in Egypt, though last year’s uprising opened the security services to relative scrutiny.

What if a similar incident took place in Egypt?

http://www.globalpost.com/dispatch/news/regions/americas/united-states/121114/the-petraeus-affair-heard-around-the-world