Connect to share and comment

This is why Saudi Arabia and Iran don't like each other

The rivalry between Saudi Arabia and Iran goes back decades, if not centuries.

Us saudi arabia iran syria talks invitationEnlarge
Saudi Foreign Minister Prince Saud al-Faisal bin Abdulaziz al-Saud listens as US Secretary of State John Kerry makes a statement to journalists at King Khalid International Airport in Riyadh on Jan. 5, 2014. Both countries are opposed to Iran attending this week's Syria peace conference. (BRENDAN SMIALOWSKI/AFP/Getty Images)

All the key players were at the table in Switzerland as the Syria peace conference began in Montreux on Wednesday.

All except one.

The peace talks, dubbed Geneva II, nearly fell apart before they began, when United Nations Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon extended an invitation to Iran on Sunday.

Iran is a key financial and military backer of Syrian President Bashar al-Assad’s regime.

Ban issued the last-minute invite after he was assured by Iran's Foreign Minister Mohammad Javad Zarif that the country would "play a very positive and constructive role."

By Monday evening, with the Syrian opposition threatening to withdraw from Geneva II, and  the United States and other Western powers urging the UN to rescind its invitation, Iran had lost its spot at the Syria peace talks.

More from GlobalPost: Iran invite to Syria peace talks imperils Geneva conference

The United States and other western powers opposed Iran's attendance based on its refusal to accept a communique — adopted at the first Geneva talks on June 30, 2012 — calling for a transitional government in Syria.

But perhaps no one was more enraged at the idea of sharing a table with Iran than regional powerhouse Saudi Arabia, which is a major supporter of the Syrian opposition and a historic foe of Iran.

Then Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad greeting Syrian President Bashar al-Assad in Tehran on October 02, 2010. (Atta Kenare/AFP/Getty Images)

Iran did not "announce officially and openly its agreement (to)... the creation of a transitional government," the Saudi government said on Monday in an official statement.

This rendered Iran "unqualified to attend."

Riyadh’s response should come as no surprise. Oil-rich Saudi Arabia and Iran are not only divided by the Persian Gulf, but also along religious lines.

Saudi Arabia has a predominantly Sunni Muslim population, while Iran is mostly Shiite (Shia).

Both countries have been locked in a cold war for decades as they battle for religious, political and economic dominance in the region.

To better understand this rivalry, GlobalPost selected four articles explaining the complex relationship between Saudi Arabia and Iran in the context of the United States, Syria, the Arab Spring and the recent nuclear deal with Tehran.

"Explaining the Iran-Saudi rivalry" by University of South Florida Prof. Mohsen M. Milani on CNN

Milani wrote: "Iran and Saudi Arabia are neither natural allies nor natural enemies but natural rivals who have long competed as major oil producers and self-proclaimed defenders of Shia (Shiite) and Sunni Islam, respectively. Until the Iranian revolution in 1979, their rivalry was managed and controlled by the United States, with whom they were both strategic allies.

"But after the Shah was overthrown, Saudi Arabia’s leadership became frightened by the Ayatollah Khomenei’s denunciation of the Saudi monarchy as antithetical to Islam and his ambition to export to the revolution to the Arab world. Saudi Arabia remained an ally of the United States; Iran became an implacable foe. Thereafter, the rivalry between Iran and Saudi Arabia became defined by the new US strategy – ally with Saudi Arabia to offset Iran."

Iran's Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei (R) meets then Saudi Crown Prince Abdullah ibn Abdel Aziz in 1997. (AFP/Getty Images)

"Rivals — Iran vs. Saudi Arabia" Q & A with Middle East scholars Christopher Boucek and Karim Sadjadpour in the Carnegie Endowment

Boucek (who died of a heart attack two months after the article was published) made this point: "The challenge is that both countries view power and influence in the region as a zero-sum game. If Iran gains, Saudi Arabia loses — and vice versa. In Saudi Arabia there is not just a fear that Iran wants a greater role in the region, there is alarm that Iran wants to control the region. Saudi Arabia often seems to view the region through sectarian lenses and wants to unite people under the sectarian umbrella of Sunnis. Riyadh therefore views the ascendency of Shias and the war in the region in zero-sum terms."

"Why the Iran Deal Scares Saudi Arabia" by Brookings Doha Center non-resident senior fellow F. Gregory Gause in The New Yorker

Gause wrote that Iran's nuclear ambitions were not the Saudis' only concern: "They have a more profound fear: that geopolitical trends in the Middle East are aligning against them, threatening both their regional stature and their domestic security. The Saudis see an Iran that is dominant in Iraq and Lebanon, holding onto its ally in Syria, and now forging a new relationship with Washington — a rival, in short, without any obstacles to regional dominance, and one further emboldened to encourage Shiite populations in the Gulf monarchies, including Saudi Arabia, to oppose their Sunni rulers."

Iranian clerics holding up anti-Saudi King Abdullah posters during a protest in Tehran in 2011. (Atta Kenare/AFP/Getty Images)

"Iran-Saudi Arabia: A troubled affair" op-ed by Khosrow Soltani, senior journalist based in Tehran for Al Jazeera

Soltani talked about the importance of a détente between the rivals: "During the 1960s and 1970s the two countries were in a strategic alliance with considerable political, military and security interactions. The West, and the US in particular, used these two states to deter the influence of Soviet communism in the Middle East.

"The change following the Islamic Revolution in 1979 dealt a heavy blow to the interests and ambitions of the West and the US in the Middle East, and also took some allies, including Saudi Arabia, by surprise. Tehran-Riyadh relations then entered a new stage fraught with mistrust and hostility."
 

http://www.globalpost.com/dispatch/news/regions/middle-east/140120/saudi-arabia-iran-rivalry-relationship