Pakistani Taliban fighters sit with their weapons on the back of a truck in Buner, about 60 miles northwest of Islamabad April 24, 2009. (Reuters)
News of Pakistan's doom greatly exaggerated
Analysis: Fears that the Taliban are about to overrun Pakistan's seat of power seem unfounded.
NEW YORK — A bronze statue of Giuseppe Garibaldi stands in Washington Square Park, recognizing the 19th-century Italian war hero who assembled the first recruits for his Red Shirts militia here in New York City.
The fighters, known for their matching flannel outfits, traveled to Italy by sea to help Garibaldi fight in the Italian unification wars that led to the creation of the modern European nation state.
The Red Shirts became the inspiration for Mussolini’s Black Shirts and Hitler’s Brown Shirts, the armed groups that muscled the fascist political parties to power in a warring Europe decades later.
While the Taliban in Pakistan prefer the traditional shalwar-kameez to flannel and don’t bother much with matching outfits, they do bear some resemblance to the armed bands that brought revolutionary change in Europe in the past century.
I flew back to New York last month after a six-month reporting tour in Pakistan. During my time in the Islamic republic I covered more than a few major-league fiascoes — the attacks in Mumbai that ignited an international political crisis in nuclear South Asia; the march by hundreds of thousands of lawyers and political activists on the capital while threatening to overthrow the government; the day that terrorists took to the streets of Pakistan’s second largest city, Lahore, in broad daylight and machine gunned a busload of international athletes.
But the biggest news was often about the encroaching Taliban militias in the north, the same militias that have now reportedly reached within 60 miles of the capital, Islamabad.
Incredibly, the sense of impending doom felt by those outside the country was rarely felt from within. While based in Islamabad — with its wide tree-lined avenues, glitzy restaurants and sky-high real estate market — or while visiting Lahore — a city of 10 million with a thriving art and music scene — or reporting from Karachi — with its buzzing nightlife and daytime financial bustle — or even inside the war-torn tribal areas or in the city of Peshawar that is under the barrel of the Taliban gun — I never feared that the country would soon be ruled by the small Pashtun guerrilla force.
Maybe because it likely won't.
Shahan, great piece here and an important antidote to the oversimplified analysis of Pakistan's politics so prevalent in the U.S. Thank you for taking a step back and examining the more nuanced threat the militants pose!
Recent on Pakistan :
Adventure travel: The Great Himalaya Trail?
Jason Overdorf - India - February 4, 2010 07:11 ET
Why walk Everest, K2, and other mountain giants? Because they are there.
How an accused secret agent has tied up India-Pakistan-US relations
Sonya Fatah - India - December 23, 2009 06:51 ET
Since David Coleman Headley was taken into custody, suspicion in India about Pakistan and the US has grown.
Opinion: Not enough troops for counterinsurgency
C.M. Sennott - Worldview - December 1, 2009 23:15 ET
Obama's Afghanistan speech did not convince counterinsurgency experts and did not give enough details.
Opinion: It's really about Pakistan
HDS Greenway - Worldview - December 1, 2009 22:33 ET
Obama's speech hints at the ultimate strategic importance of Pakistan, rather than Afghanistan.
Opinion: Obama has a hard sell on Afghanistan troop increase
C.M. Sennott - Worldview - November 25, 2009 19:19 ET
Will a commitment to "finish the job" end up ringing just as hollow as "mission accomplished?"
Karachi: A place for all souls
H.M. Naqvi - Pakistan - November 7, 2009 16:59 ET
Pakistan, intended as a place for India's Muslims after partition, makes its Christians and Hindus feel welcome, too.
How can they resist it?
Sonya Fatah - Pakistan - October 30, 2009 06:46 ET
Bombs, fear and "Mamma Mia!"
Sonya Fatah - Pakistan - October 30, 2009 06:45 ET
Hundreds packed into a Karachi theater to see a local cast perform the hit Broadway musical.
Interview: Ambassador Ryan Crocker
C.M. Sennott - Worldview - October 19, 2009 09:16 ET
The longtime diplomat says Obama needs to choose an AfPak strategy before the Taliban further consolidates its hold.
Full Frame: When peace deals break down
Edwin Koo - Full Frame - October 15, 2009 14:51 ET
A photographic journey through Pakistan's refugee camps.
Scientist reveals India nuke test fizzled
Jason Overdorf - India - September 30, 2009 08:12 ET
A top scientist's claim that India's 1998 nuclear test was a failure poses a big threat to Obama's nonproliferation plans.
Opinion: Weighing Holbrooke's "last mission"
HDS Greenway - Worldview - September 29, 2009 15:40 ET
A recent article explores the demons and obsessions dogging Obama's Af-Pak envoy.
The coming war for water
Jason Overdorf - India - September 24, 2009 23:22 ET
Kashmir's mighty rivers are a source of strife on the subcontinent.
India's hidden war heats up
Jason Overdorf - India - September 24, 2009 05:33 ET
As New Delhi steps up its fight against Maoist rebels, casualties mount.
Opinion: Could US-British cooperation have caught more terrorists?
Michael Goldfarb - United Kingdom - September 8, 2009 18:42 ET
In a second trial, three British men were convicted on 2006 charges of plotting to blow up airplanes.
Discussion: US taxpayers sponsor the Taliban
David Case - Afghanistan - September 4, 2009 15:55 ET
On Sept. 10, we will host a conference call with our Kabul correspondent, who prompted a government investigation into aid money flowing to the Taliban.
Funding the Pakistani Taliban
Shahan Mufti - Pakistan - September 4, 2009 11:32 ET
Poppies, tobacco and the "timber mafia." But that's not all.
The stones of Srinagar
Jason Overdorf - India - August 27, 2009 11:35 ET
On the streets of this political hotspot, chucking rocks at the police is the most cherished form of free speech.
Life, death and the Taliban: Blowback
C.M. Sennott - Afghanistan - August 19, 2009 21:54 ET
What we don't know is killing us.
Watch GlobalPost videos:
Reporter's Notebook
A large bomb blast at a five-star Peshawar hotel has killed at least 11 people including foreign nationals, according to local media reports. I was...Read more >
"So long as our relationship is defined by our differences, we will empower those who sow hatred rather than peace ... ." President...Read more >
Here's a perplexing update from Lahore... Two days after one of the worst terrorist bombing in the city's history that killed 30 people and a day...Read more >
Featured: Special Projects
Oceans:
Assessing their health
After the Fall:
20 years since the Berlin Wall came down
Life, Death and the Taliban:
Videos and stories
Study Abroad:
Students report from the road
Living in the Shadows:
An intimate look at China's migrant workers
A World of Trouble:
The global economy in 20 hotspots
Comments:
1 Comments.
Login or Register to post comments