How much did Russia know about Manas negotiations?

Moscow might not have a choice other than to accept the US presence at the Kyrgyzstan air base.

By David L. Stern - GlobalPost
Published: July 2, 2009 13:26 ET
Page 2 of 2

Moscow immediately put a positive spin on the U-turn. President Medvedev said that he welcomed the decision, while the Russian foreign ministry said Kyrgyzstan was acting in its rights as a “sovereign nation.”

Not everybody was so sanguine, however. An unnamed senior Russian diplomat told Russia’s Kommersant newspaper that the Kyrgyz had played a “dirty trick” and Moscow would carry out an “adequate response.”

Konstantin Zatulin, a Duma deputy with close ties to the Kremlin and foreign policy establishment, nevertheless believes that Moscow did give its blessing to the negotiations. “Obama’s arrival played a substantive, important role [in the Kremlin’s position]. He created the ground for a new Russian-American relationship.”

Others do not doubt that some Russian officials are dissatisfied, but in the end their opinions matter little. “We have only two ‘senior diplomats’ — Putin and Medvedev,” said Aleksei Malashenko, a Eurasia expert at the Carnegie Center in Moscow, referring to Russian Prime Minister Vladimir Putin.

If the Russians were on board, some experts wonder if they received anything for their acquiescence — an American concession to abandon an anti-missile defense shield in Eastern Europe, for example. This, however, would be a risky move, as it could be interpreted as a betrayal of the two countries that pushed for the shield, Poland and the Czech Republic.

But others say that the Russians were in fact not informed until the last minute. This raises the question of what measures they will take next. Just prior to the decision to kick the Americans out, Kyrgyzstan experienced a debilitating cyber-attack which some experts subscribed to the Kremlin.

On the other hand, the Americans may have simply handed the Russians a fait accompli, which Moscow, on the eve of its first summit with the new president, will have to accept.

“My sense is that they are as mad as hell,” said Stephen Blank, a professor of national securities studies at the U.S. Army War College. “They thought they had it locked up and we beat them.”

More on Manas air base:

The path to Afghanistan now runs through Central Asia

Why the air base debate drags on

Manas Air Base: A Pyrrhic victory?

Comments:

2 Comments.

Login or Register to post comments

Posted by Garvagh on July 3, 2009 18:05 ET

Russia has a large interest in a stable Afghanistan, and the American willingness to squander hundreds of billions of dollars on this military adventure presents a spectacle for the Russians to behold. The US role in Central Asia is already too large, and there is nothing in the category of "victory" that can be achieved by the application of American military power.

Posted by vonrock on July 5, 2009 21:54 ET

You said it Brother, and P. T. Barnum said it another way, There's a sucker born every minute. we just happen to come along at the right time. and that 180mill. will be 280 by thursday. that must be some airport, and a real drug hub too.

Recent on Russia and its neighbors:

Swine flu panic — and politics — hit Ukraine

David L. Stern - Russia and its neighbors - November 10, 2009 06:46 ET

The H1N1 outbreak has led Ukrainian officials to accuse each other of inappropriate responses.

Opinion: The day after the Wall fell

Michael Moran - Worldview - November 9, 2009 17:55 ET

The fears of Germany and its neighbors in 1989 have largely been resolved by 2009.

Can US political consultants sway Ukrainian voters?

David L. Stern - Russia and its neighbors - October 30, 2009 12:46 ET

AKPD advises aspiring presidential candidate Yulia Tymoshenko.

Opinion: A hidden deal on Iran sanctions?

David J. Kramer - Worldview - October 17, 2009 09:11 ET

Since Russia and China will not be on board, one can only hope the Obama Administration has other plans, writes David J. Kramer.

Russia, Belarus play war together

David L. Stern - Russia and its neighbors - October 16, 2009 15:24 ET

But despite appearances, the neighbors are not the best of friends.

Armenia and Turkey — not so fast

David L. Stern - Turkey - October 14, 2009 17:28 ET

Obstacles to reopening the two countries' border include Azerbaijan, parliamentary approval and the weight of history.

Communism: a love affair?

Miriam Elder - Russia and its neighbors - October 14, 2009 17:14 ET

The tyranny of daily bribes has many Russians nostalgic for Soviet social services.

A World of Trouble: Is the nightmare over?

Thomas Mucha - Commerce - October 14, 2009 13:35 ET

With signs of economic recovery finally emerging, here's where things stand in 20 countries around the world.

Swine flu causes controversy in Russia

Miriam Elder - Russia and its neighbors - October 13, 2009 11:24 ET

One official accuses the other of a "terrorist act" for reporting a possible swine flu death.

Moscow opposition complains of intimidation

Miriam Elder - Russia and its neighbors - October 10, 2009 08:00 ET

The ruling United Russia party expects a strong showing in municipal elections despite Russia's ailing economy.

Moldova, where Lenin still stands

David L. Stern - Europe - October 9, 2009 06:07 ET

How the Communist Party has held on to Moldovans' votes.

Analysis: Obama strikes a tough tone on Iran

C.M. Sennott - Worldview - September 30, 2009 18:50 ET

But the diplomacy needed to get Iran to halt its nuclear program will require more than tone.

Report puts Georgia on the defensive

David L. Stern and Miriam Elder - Russia and its neighbors - September 30, 2009 14:06 ET

An EU-sponsored report on the 2008 Russia-Georgia war blames both countries.

The Nets' likely new owner is lucky and tall

Miriam Elder - Russia and its neighbors - September 23, 2009 16:58 ET

Learn more about Mikhail Prokhorov, Russia's richest man and future owner of the New Jersey Nets.

That Russian ship? Still idling.

Miriam Elder - Russia and its neighbors - September 23, 2009 06:18 ET

As the Arctic Sea remains off the coast of the Canary Islands, questions about its cargo deepen.

G20 Pittsburgh: They meet again

Michael Goldfarb - Worldview - September 22, 2009 06:13 ET

Opinion: The world does not hold its breath.

Opinion: Obama's move was not appeasement

HDS Greenway - Worldview - September 18, 2009 16:51 ET

The only purpose for a missile defense shield in Eastern Europe was to provoke Russia.

Russia's Stalin revival

Miriam Elder - Russia and its neighbors - September 15, 2009 08:31 ET

But Moscow's little-visited Gulag Museum tells a darker history of the Soviet Union and Josef Stalin.

Former republics buck Russia's influence

David L. Stern - Russia and its neighbors - September 13, 2009 08:35 ET

Despite Russia's aggression toward Georgia, other former satellites go their own way.