Kobe Bryant of the Los Angeles Lakers stands on court during Game 1 of the NBA Final against the Orlando Magic at the Staples Center in Los Angeles on June 4, 2009. (Gabriel Bouys/AFP/Getty Images)
The greatest ... or not
Opinion: A short shelf life for greatness.
“Great” used to be such a great word.
Back — way back almost a century ago — it truly connoted something.
We had a Great War, a Great Depression and, in between those two, a great fictional character, Jay Gatsby, whose embodiment of the American dream is a model of literary endurance. And nobody regarded any of that adjectival action as a matter of overstatement.
But today “great” no longer suffices. Today we require “greatest” and use it so indiscriminately that the concept is being thoroughly depreciated.
Nowhere is that truer than in the realm of sports. Every book now trumpets “the greatest game,” “the greatest match,” “the greatest player,” as if the writer couldn’t possibly convince a reader if he hadn’t already insisted upon it up front.
And, of course, “the greatest ever” spills off our sports pages with stunning frequency. Over the past weekend in sports, a busy but hardly epic one, the “greatest” debate was triggered by three different sporting events showcasing three different athletes: by tennis’s French Open (Roger Federer with his record-tying 14th major title), by golf's Memorial Tournament (Tiger Woods, of course), and by a Los Angeles Lakers victory in the second game of the NBA Finals (Kobe Bryant transcendent.)
The resurrection of Kobe as the putative heir to Michael Jordan — and quite possibly better than the original — shows just how silly the entire exercise is. It was only a couple weeks ago that LeBron James reigned supreme and was getting the nod over Bryant, not only for the league’s MVP Award but also for the top spot in basketball’s eternal pantheon. The conventional wisdom of the moment was that LeBron could hurt an opponent in more ways than Kobe, which lasted until he couldn’t hurt Orlando in enough ways to carry his Cleveland Cavaliers into the Finals. The very fact of this debate reveals the shelf life for unrivaled greatness at no more than a decade. Which is silly. Even if your memory doesn’t span back that far, mine does and — trust me — nobody was better than Michael Jordan.
Tiger’s bumpy recovery from his most recent knee surgery had some experts convinced that he would never again dominate and might not catch Jack Nicklaus’ record for major championships, which had once been a foregone conclusion. Without that record, some wondered, what claim would he have to “greatest golfer ever”? His come-from-behind victory last weekend at the tourney Nicklaus himself hosts was a timely reminder of his incomparable prowess. Majors are one measure of the man, but hardly the only one. Tiger does not require any crowning achievement (though I fully expect him to pass Nicklaus). He is the best ever by virtue of the stranglehold he has maintained on the game — for more than a decade and in a far more competitive era.
Recent on Sports:
Russian figure skater makes comeback for country
Mark Starr - Sports - February 9, 2010 07:23 ET
Evgeni Plushenko rises from retirement to maintain Russia's reputation at the top of men's skating.
Adventure travel: The Great Himalaya Trail?
Jason Overdorf - India - February 4, 2010 07:11 ET
Why walk Everest, K2, and other mountain giants? Because they are there.
Golf’s “cheating” controversy
Mark Starr - Sports - February 2, 2010 10:48 ET
It might sound like small potatoes, but the dispute over grooved clubs has tarnished the gentlemen's sport.
In the African Cup of Nations, Egypt has God on its side
Mark Starr - Sports - January 27, 2010 07:45 ET
To even make the team, Egyptians soccer players must pass religious litmus test. FIFA doesn't seem to mind.
Soweto's Vilakazi Street spruces up
Erin Conway-Smith - South Africa - January 26, 2010 06:37 ET
World Cup will highlight historic street that was home to 2 Nobel prize-winners.
Anti-Israel protests target young tennis star
Mark Starr - Sports - January 22, 2010 09:03 ET
In response, 22-year-old Shahar Peer insists politics have nothing to do with her match on the court.
Dominican dreams, Part 2: Miguel Angel Sano
Casey Beck and Trevor Martin - Sports - January 22, 2010 08:36 ET
Angolan violence scars African soccer tournament
Mark Starr - Worldview - January 11, 2010 16:58 ET
Separatist attack on Togo team prompts questions about World Cup in South Africa.
The uniquely scandalous nature of American college athletics
Mark Starr - Sports - January 7, 2010 10:12 ET
Unlike other countries, where clubs and junior leagues precede the pros, American colleges serve as feeders — and unholy ones at that.
The top 10 sports figures who helped define a year
Mark Starr - Sports - January 1, 2010 09:08 ET
And one New Year's wish: that the glories of sport trump the inglorious in the coming year.
Tiger and Elin Woods' new home: surrounded by ice
Marcus Oscarsson - Sports - December 13, 2009 13:00 ET
The rustic Swedish estate purchased by Elin Nordegren Woods doesn't have indoor plumbing during winter.
Can Elin go home again?
Marcus Oscarsson - Sports - December 13, 2009 12:50 ET
How Elin Nordegren Woods, known by one name in her native land, epitomizes the Swedish character.
Tiger Woods: A golfer still, but on whose team?
Mark Starr - Sports - December 11, 2009 09:21 ET
Golf will be back in the Olympics in 2016. But whether Woods will be there to show for it — and on whose team — remains an open question.
Highlights from the 2010 World Cup draw
Mark Starr - Sports - December 4, 2009 17:34 ET
South Africa was more than a little unlucky, but for the US there is hope where there was once despair.
Opinion: Hey FIFA, how low can you go?
Mark Starr - Sports - November 25, 2009 07:07 ET
On the sinking integrity of soccer's international governing body and why the World Cup will be regarded with suspicion.
Outraged Ireland demands a replay
Conor O'Clery - Ireland - November 19, 2009 11:53 ET
A French hand ball puts Ireland out of the World Cup.
World Cup: Bad soccer!
Mark Starr - Sports - November 17, 2009 12:29 ET
The backdrop of South Africa promises to be colorful, but the footwork on the field may leave a bit to be desired.
"Damned United" and the tragedy at Leeds
Mark Starr - Sports - November 13, 2009 21:56 ET
A genuine soccer movie tells the story of Brian Clough, the greatest soccer coach in England to never coach the national team.
A kick in the buck
Cristina Mateo-Yanguas - Spain - November 13, 2009 06:25 ET
Why the elimination of a tax break could spell the end of glory days for Spanish club soccer.
Opinion: ALS, Lou Gehrig and Michael
Mark Starr - Worldview - November 8, 2009 10:16 ET
How one man's struggle with ALS called on Major League Baseball to take a stand.
Watch GlobalPost videos:
Reporter's Notebook
It was a game that will shut the English up — at least for a day or two. There were no ifs, ands or buts coming from the mouths of...Read more >
Featured: Special Projects
Oceans:
Assessing their health
After the Fall:
20 years since the Berlin Wall came down
Life, Death and the Taliban:
Videos and stories
Study Abroad:
Students report from the road
Living in the Shadows:
An intimate look at China's migrant workers
A World of Trouble:
The global economy in 20 hotspots
Comments:
No Comments.
Login or Register to post comments