A line of American soldiers march up a hill in Vietnam during the Route 9 offensive while fires behind them send smoke into the air in 1968. (Larry Burrows/Time Magazine/Getty Images)

The pitfalls of pacification

As Obama unveils new efforts in Afghanistan, it is worth a look at what happened in Vietnam. Part two in a series.

By Matt Steinglass - GlobalPost
Published: March 27, 2009 09:15 ET
Updated: March 30, 2009 20:12 ET

LONG AN PROVINCE, Vietnam — My Hanh, 20 miles west of Ho Chi Minh City, is a prosperous town of brick and concrete farmhouses interspersed with huge Japanese-owned electronics factories.

When Cai Van Minh, 56, was growing up during the Vietnam War, My Hanh was a tiny village surrounded by an unbroken expanse of rice paddies and thatched-roof bamboo huts. In March 1963, the South Vietnamese government ordered Minh and his family to leave My Hanh, relocating them into a brand-new “strategic hamlet” half a mile away called Tram Lac.

The Saigon government was building the hamlets as part of an all-out push to defeat the increasingly aggressive communist Viet Cong insurgency, which already effectively governed much of the territory of South Vietnam.

The “strategic hamlets” campaign was one of the first major U.S.-backed counterinsurgency efforts in the Vietnam War, which lasted from 1960 to 1975 and killed at least 3 million Vietnamese and 58,000 Americans. (Click here to read the first part of this series: Lessons of Vietnam.)

The same year that Minh’s family was relocated, a 22-year-old American foreign service officer was posted to a province in Vietnam's Mekong Delta, where he found himself running the province's "strategic hamlets" program.

It was the officer's first experience with insurgent warfare in a career that would involve many. The officer was Richard Holbrooke, who is now U.S. President Barack Obama's special envoy to Afghanistan and Pakistan, charged with the diplomatic side of American efforts to defeat the Taliban insurgency. And while the details differ, many of the problems the U.S. faces today in Afghanistan are the same as those Holbrooke faced at the beginning of his career in Vietnam.

The idea of the strategic hamlet was first put forward by the British officer Robert Thompson and the visionary CIA officer William Colby. It was modeled on a program that helped the British defeat a communist insurgency in Malaya in the early 1950s.

The aim of the program was to separate the Viet Cong from the population they depended on. Chinese communist ruler Mao Zedong had said a guerrilla army moves among the people like a fish in water. Now South Vietnam’s authoritarian anti-communist president, Ngo Dinh Diem, vowed he would “drain the pond to catch the fish.”

Comments:

No Comments.

Login or Register to post comments

Recent on Vietnam:

Silicon Sweatshops: A promising model

Jonathan Adams and Kathleen E. McLaughlin - China and its neighbors - November 18, 2009 06:54 ET

There's no easy way to police supply chains in Asia. But one US high-tech firm and its Taiwan supplier are taking a creative approach that might just work.

Special report: Silicon Sweatshops

Jonathan Adams and Kathleen E. McLaughlin - China and its neighbors - November 17, 2009 15:05 ET

Despite strict "codes of conduct," labor rights violations are the norm at factories making the world's favorite high-tech gadgets.

What do you think about Silicon Sweatshops?

News Desk - China and its neighbors - November 17, 2009 15:04 ET

Are high-tech supply chains in Asia good business or exploitation? You decide.

Silicon Sweatshops: Shattered dreams

Jonathan Adams - China and its neighbors - November 17, 2009 07:24 ET

Migrant workers making gadgets at Taiwan's high-tech parks sign deals that make them modern-day indentured servants.

Silicon Sweatshops: The China connection

Kathleen E. McLaughlin and Jonathan Adams - China and its neighbors - November 17, 2009 07:22 ET

For migrant workers, an electronics factory job can be a ticket into China's booming middle class. But for many, it turns into a nightmare of poor working conditions and indifferent bosses.

Silicon Sweatshops: Disposable workforce

Jonathan Adams - China and its neighbors - November 17, 2009 07:22 ET

Laid-off Taiwanese workers accuse their firm of violating industry codes even when times were good.

A World of Trouble: Is the nightmare over?

Thomas Mucha - Commerce - October 14, 2009 13:35 ET

With signs of economic recovery finally emerging, here's where things stand in 20 countries around the world.

Clean burning stoves in Vietnam

Matt Steinglass - Vietnam - October 3, 2009 11:05 ET

News analysis: Malaysian model drinks beer, asks to be caned

Thomas Mucha - Commerce - August 24, 2009 06:25 ET

The wacky story of the week comes from, where else, Asia?

Meet the economic gangsters

Mark Scheffler - Commerce - August 12, 2009 09:03 ET

Economic gangsters come in all shapes and sizes — they're Asian dictators and Somali pirates.

Fears of a nuclear Burma

Patrick Winn - Thailand - July 22, 2009 12:15 ET

The evidence, the conspirators and one "very concerned" Hillary Clinton

Kerry: "We are going to take a hard look at Afghanistan"

John Aloysius Farrell - Diplomacy - July 10, 2009 14:21 ET

In an interview, Sen. John F. Kerry recalls his appearance at Vietnam hearings and says he will hold them on Afghanistan.

Hydropower projects drying up central Vietnam's water supplies

VietNamNet - Vietnam - July 6, 2009 13:41 ET

VietNamNet Bridge reports on the environmental consequences of a rapid build-up.

The biggest cave in the world

VietNamNet - Vietnam - July 6, 2009 13:33 ET

VietNamNet Bridge reports on what some subterranean scientists are calling "the find of the century."

All-electric, all-Texas

Matt Steinglass - Vietnam - June 22, 2009 07:25 ET

Video: How a high-tech electric engine from the Lone Star State could change the face of Vietnam.

Footloose in Hanoi

Matt Steinglass - Vietnam - June 21, 2009 09:41 ET

Faced with a rise in drugs and prostitution, Vietnam bans .... dancing?

A World of Trouble, the sequel

Thomas Mucha - Commerce - June 15, 2009 06:40 ET

Special Report: It's still ugly out there.

VietNamNet: Help wanted?

VietNamNet - Vietnam - May 13, 2009 08:30 ET

Recruitment leaflets seeking workers are appearing in Ho Chi Minh City.

Crisis puts migrant workers in a bind

Bruce I. Konviser - Czech Republic - April 22, 2009 11:39 ET

Some Vietnamese paid so much to get to Prague, it's impossible for them to return home.