
Avigdor Lieberman, leader of Yisrael Beiteinu party, is flanked by security personnel after a visit to the Western Wall in Jerusalem's Old City Feb. 9, 2009. (Damir Sagolj/Reuters)
Avidgor Lieberman, kingmaker or king?
Opinion: On Winston Churchill, Peter the Great, and the future of autocratic rule in Israel
No one knows who got elected prime minister in Israel's election last week. The vote produced a virtual tie between Benjamin Netanyahu and Tzipi Livni. It's clear, though, who won the job of kingmaker: far rightist Avigdor Lieberman, whose party took third place in the proportional vote. By backing one candidate or the other, he can decide who will have enough support in parliament to form a ruling coalition.
And this is deeply ironic. Lieberman does not dream of being the power behind the throne. He dreams of the throne.
As soon as the votes were counted, both Livni and Netanyahu began courting Lieberman and his Israel Is Our Home party. Lieberman, a burly man with icy, pale eyes and a trimmed beard, is known for his antipathy toward Israel's Arab minority. His legislative program includes a bill that would condition citizenship on swearing loyalty to the country, its flag and its anthem. Since Israeli Arabs are unhappy with the anthem, which refers to the “Jewish soul,” and with the flag, which features a six-pointed Jewish star, the obvious goal is to make them refuse the oath and lose their right to vote.
Lieberman also talks of reforms that would create a more stable government. His party's proposal on the subject deserves a closer reading than it usually gets. It would allow the prime minister to appoint cabinet members without parliamentary approval. Under a state of emergency declared by parliament, the cabinet — or even the prime minister by himself — could enact emergency regulations that supercede laws. It's worth noting that Israel has officially been in a state of emergency since the day it became independent. Lieberman's proposal is a blueprint for autocratic rule.
Lieberman, 50, immigrated from Soviet Moldova in 1980. He was Netanyahu's closest ally within the right-wing Likud party before he decided he'd rather be Number 1 than Number 2, and formed his own party. Two years ago, I interviewed him in his Knesset office, and asked him what person or book had most influenced him. He mentioned Winston Churchill who, he says, was attacked in the years before World War II as being a "warmonger, embittered, extremist," the same insults Lieberman feels he's suffered.
But his deepest admiration and enthusiasm were reserved for Peter the Great. He had read "Peter the First," a Soviet-era novel about the autocrat "at least 300 times,” he told me. "Whenever I am tired or upset and I want something to calm me,” he said, "I open it on any page and start to read."
So I got an English copy of the novel. It was written by Alexey Tolstoy, a relative of the author of "War and Peace." The novel describes Peter, coming to power at the end of the 17th century, as the heir to a backward Asiatic Russia. He sees his calling as making his land modern and European, by any means necessary — "to drag the people out of their age-old swamp, open their eyes, prod them in the ribs. Beat them, lick them into shape, teach them.” When he faces a rebellion, “The prisons were filled and thousands of new corpses swayed … on the walls of Moscow.” The czar himself takes part in torturing the conspirators.
Alexey Tolstoy's granddaughter and biographer, I discovered, teaches Russian literature at Hebrew University — a sign of the vast intellectual migration of the post-Soviet years. Her grandfather wrote the book during Stalin's time, hinting to the dictator that "we want a progressive, Western country,” she said. Yet Stalin saw himself in the novel's depiction of the czar who brought progress through cruelty. It seemed to me that Stalin read the book well.
"One cannot understand modern Russia without reading this book," Lieberman told me. In the process, he told me how to understand his dreams, and it made me tremble.
Lieberman now wants wants one of the three top cabinet posts — defense, foreign affairs or finance. He also wants support for his legislative program. Both Livni and Netanyahu have been ready to bargain with him.
But for Lieberman, the current round is just a step on the path. Eventually, he expects to be not the kingmaker, but the king.
Gershom Gorenberg is the author of "The Accidental Empire: Israel and the Birth of the Settlements, 1967-1977" (Times Books), and he blogs at southjerusalem.com. He originally interviewed Avigdor Lieberman for the Atlantic Monthly.
More GlobalPost dispatches about Israel:
Netanyahu will try to form a government, but it may not last for long.
After the parliamentary elections, the results remained unclear.
Lieberman seems to be quite a puzzle to many people, especially the secular, anti-religious-party faction in Israel. Although he is a xenophobic right-winger who baits the Arabs mercilessly, he is also relentlessly secular, and goads the religious fanatics as well. But it seems sensible to me just to be frank and call him a fascist.
I remember when my brothers and I were growing up in the '50s, our father and mother were disdainful of most American politicians but full of admiration for Israel's leaders. I well remember my dad comparing Weitzman, Ben-Gurion, Golda Meir, Abba Eban, Sharett, Allon and some of the others to America's founding fathers, and not considering that the Israeli founders were in any way short of the American revolutionary ideal.
And now? Let's be honest; Israel is saddled with bums. Kadima, founded by the thuggish Arab-killer Sharon, is now considered the "moderate" or "center" party, and parties to its right -- in other words, REALLY far-right, including Lieberman's party -- won more than half the seats in the recent parliamentary election, and it seems certain that the unspeakable Netanyahoo will be the next prime minister. To make it even worse, the two (shrinking) parties of the Left are run by jerks who boast that they are willing to go to war even more quickly than the Right.
Mr. Gorenberg cites the luminous, reaching-out, rewriting-the-old-tired-script actions taken by Anwar Sadat, Pope Wojtyla and now Barack Obama as what some Israeli politician should aspire to. Would it be kosher to remark that one might as well ask pigs to fly?
Recent on Worldview:
Opinion: Why sanctions aren't the answer for Iran
Joel Brinkley - Worldview - November 6, 2009 15:45 ET
America needs to understand that punitive measures aren't going to keep Iran in check. Not when Russia and China have a lot to lose.
Opinion: Educating our way out of the crisis
Desmond Bermingham - Worldview - November 6, 2009 07:34 ET
After global finances and climate change, education should be number three for the G20.
Crossing the border, 1990
Michael Moran - Worldview - November 6, 2009 06:47 ET
After the Berlin Wall fell, Michael Moran explored the strange new world on the border of East and West.
Afghanistan: The fog of war
Finbarr O'Reilly - Afghanistan - November 5, 2009 10:51 ET
Video: Embedded with Canadian troops, photographer Finbarr O'Reilly captures the confusion and chaos of a worsening conflict.
The sinister echoes of November 9
David Binder - Worldview - November 5, 2009 05:30 ET
Germans might not celebrate the day the wall came down, but they are secure in their unity, writes David Binder.
Book excerpt: "Emancipation"
Michael Goldfarb - Worldview - November 4, 2009 16:30 ET
Michael Goldfarb's new book looks at how liberating Europe's Jews from the ghetto led to revolution and renaissance.
Italy, the CIA and rendition
Michael Moran - Diplomacy - November 4, 2009 15:56 ET
Analysis: What Wednesday's stunning verdict in Rome means for the "War on Terror".
Opinion: Remembering a good news story
HDS Greenway - Worldview - November 3, 2009 12:03 ET
Despite looming questions, the first few days after the Berlin Wall fell were glorious.
Opinion: It's liberty at stake in a warming world
William H. Luers and Amy L. Luers - Worldview - November 2, 2009 19:33 ET
US Congress and Obama must seize the moment in Copenhagen to preserve liberty for future generations.
When the hammer hit the wall it felt "ja gut!"
Pete Hamill - Worldview - November 2, 2009 19:13 ET
Pete Hamill remembers those heady days 20 years ago when the symbol of Soviet domination was bludgeoned to rubble.
Emancipation: obscured by the Holocaust
Michael Goldfarb - Worldview - November 2, 2009 18:50 ET
In his new book, Michael Goldfarb reveals a century-and-a-half of Jewish liberation usually obscured by later horrors.
Emancipation: Moses Hess to Theodore Herzl
Michael Goldfarb - Worldview - November 2, 2009 18:49 ET
In his new book on the liberation of Europe's Jews from the ghetto, Michael Goldfarb looks at the legacy of Moses Hess.
Emancipation: the Jewish reformation
Michael Goldfarb - Worldview - November 2, 2009 18:45 ET
In his new book, Michael Goldfarb discusses Jewish attempts to integrate into modern society.
Opinion: Still hope for Copenhagen summit
Stephan Faris - Worldview - November 2, 2009 09:28 ET
With the US lagging, climate talks in Copenhagen may be destined to fail. But some hold out hope.
In memory of a well-traveled dog
C.M. Sennott - Worldview - November 1, 2009 10:06 ET
She vacationed in Brittany and braved the second intifada. She enjoyed French croissants and dined on bangers and mash. Maggie was quite a dog.
Whisky on (Antarctic) ice
Emily Stone - Global Green - October 30, 2009 18:28 ET
Explorer Ernest Shackleton loved his Scotch whisky. And he left a stash at the bottom of the world.
War weary Europeans test their leaders' resolve
Mort Rosenblum - Worldview - October 27, 2009 08:47 ET
In several countries contributing troops to the Afghanistan war effort, holding onto public support is half the battle.
Bittersweet: Palestinian home cooking
Matt McAllester - Worldview - October 27, 2009 06:04 ET
The best Palestinian food can only be found at home — or at Tanoreen in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn.
Hillary and the team of rivals
HDS Greenway - Worldview - October 26, 2009 19:49 ET
Madame Secretary quietly leads while special envoys Holbrook and Mitchell struggle.
Opinion: Too many handshakes?
Michael Moran - Worldview - October 25, 2009 10:13 ET
If Washington engages with Sudan it might be too much diplomacy for the left to handle.
Reporter's Notebook
Assistant Editor Stephanie S. Garlow pitched in recently to cover the story of a New Englander who was taken hostage on the high seas by Somali...Read more >
Angelica Marin, a Californian, and Fulvio Paolocci, an Italian, recently moved to Rome and file regular dispatches and multimedia for...Read more >
Gavin Blair lives in Japan and writes regular dispatches for GlobalPost: Land of rising communism The curse of the colonel Analysis: Japan looks...Read more >
Featured: Special Projects
After the Fall:
20 years since the Berlin Wall came down
Life, Death and the Taliban:
Videos and stories
Study Abroad:
Students report from the road
Living in the Shadows:
An intimate look at China's migrant workers
A World of Trouble:
The global economy in 20 hotspots
Global Blogs:







Comments:
1 Comments.
Login or Register to post comments