The ghosts of pirates

Opinion: Piracy off the coast of Somalia emerged after years of failed and flawed US policy in the region.

By Tom Fenton - Special to GlobalPost
Published: April 11, 2009 09:06 ET
Updated: April 17, 2009 20:42 ET
Page 2 of 2

When the American-led coalition chased Al Qaeda fighters out of Afghanistan in late 2001, Pentagon planners feared they might establish new bases in Africa and began training African armies to handle the potential threat. Their worst fears were realized (or so they thought) when an alliance of Somali Islamists that called itself The Union of Islamic Courts chased the warlords out of much of the country and established a rough-and-ready Islamic brand of law and order.

The Somali people were for the most part relieved to have a functioning government after years of anarchy, but the Bush administration was not pleased. It believed the new government was harboring terrorists linked to the bombing of two American embassies in Africa in 1998.

Washington had no appetite for going back into Somalia, particularly with the ghosts of Black Hawk Down. So the CIA poured money into a clumsy attempt to create an alternative government out of a collection of mutually hostile warlords.

When that plan floundered, the Pentagon tried Plan B. It organized an invasion of Somalia by that country’s traditional enemies, the Ethiopians, in 2006. Americans provided intelligence, aviation, naval support and a few special forces, but the fighting was done by Ethiopians. The invasion inflicted utter devastation on the capital, Mogadishu, and toppled the new Islamic government that was making progress stabilizing the country.

That plan failed, too. It precipitated a new round of civil war in Somalia and has left the country in the grip of a humanitarian crisis that, according to the United Nations, rivals Darfur. The Ethiopians have withdrawn, and with the exception of Somaliland (a separatist region in the north) Somalia has no effective government.

And so it has become a haven for local pirates, who pay off local warlords as necessary and operate with impunity.

How could our government have made such a blunder without provoking a wave of moral indignation from the American people? The simple answer is that most of the mainstream American media didn’t know, didn’t care, and did not want to spend the money or take the risks they would have incurred to report a nasty American proxy war in Africa.

For the most part, it is only the Africans who are paying the price for this American policy failure.

In fact, if it were not for the pirates and a riveting drama of one brave American captain held captive, few Americans would have heard anything at all about Somalia in the past few years.

Read more about Somali pirates:

History repeats itself

Lessons of the high seas

Somali pirates hold US Navy at bay

Somalia's pirates

Comments:

3 Comments.

Login or Register to post comments

Posted by Temporarily Ano... on April 12, 2009 05:21 ET

I can't say how incredible I find your analysis that Somali piracy is now the fault of the Bush administration policies of the last eight years and that the American people are ignorant about this enlightening expose because the mainstream media in which you have been a member for over 48 years is not telling them the truth as you see it.

You need to get out of London more often. And I am not a supporter of the Bush administration in case you've undoubtedly concluded.

The fact of the matter is that Somali piracy has become rampant recently for the very simple reason: it pays. And Somalia is a failed state because it was built by European colonial masters - the original pirates - from a disparate collection of tribes and clans with nothing in common.

Blaming America will not change these simple facts.

Posted by PapaGeek on April 21, 2009 14:58 ET

You mention Bill Clinton as the President who deployed US troops to Somalia, but I distinctly remember being dumbfounded (hey, I was a teenager!) when in the closing days of #41's term, HE sent troops to Somalia. Personally, I would tend to lay at least a LITTLE blame at the feet of a DraftDodger-cum-POTUS who failed to keep our troops properly equipped, instead seeking a "Peace Dividend". The dividend of peace is PEACE. When we equip soldiers to be police, and we prosecute enemy soldiers (aka terrorists) as criminals, we LOSE. We've BEEN there, we've DONE that, we're DOING it AGAIN.

Posted by Klaatu83 on April 29, 2009 14:25 ET

As an American Merchant Seaman I have absolutely no sympathy with the Somalis. Whatever problems their country is experiencing are entirely of their own making, and should not be used as an excuse to condone kidnapping an extortion perpetrated upon innocent seamen plying their trade. If piracy is flourishing it is simply because it is more profitable than fishing. Why shouldn't it continue? The steamship companies don't want to incur the expense of arming their crews or supplying armed guards. Warships from Europe and Canada simply disarm any pirates they capture and then let them go. As for the one pirate the U.S. Navy captured alive, he was grinning from ear to ear when he arrived in the States. Why shouldn't he be, when he was probably treated better than he ever had been back home? Sounds like a pretty good business to me!

Recent on Worldview:

Opinion: China has a President Hu, now Europe chooses President Who?

Michael Goldfarb - Worldview - November 20, 2009 21:12 ET

The process of elimination that led to Van Rompuy's appointment represents all that is institutionally wrong with the European Union.

Opinion: Silenced in the Sahara

Timothy Kustusch - Worldview - November 20, 2009 10:52 ET

"Saharawi Gandhi" was expelled from the Western Sahara and is now on hunger strike.

Opinion: How to finance the war in Afghanistan?

C.M. Sennot - Worldview - November 20, 2009 06:32 ET

A question that, for Obama, is likely to hit home all the way over there in China.

Opinion: How best to get things done in Afghanistan and elsewhere

Mort Rosenblum - Worldview - November 19, 2009 12:35 ET

Or, the art of speaking loudly behind a door firmly closed.

Opinion: In France, l’Etat is no longer moi

Mort Rosenblum - Worldview - November 17, 2009 06:41 ET

Dodging corruption charges and facing jail time, French leaders go out of their way to give Louis XIV a bad name.

International visitors buoy US tourism industry

Susan E. Reed - Worldview - November 15, 2009 09:30 ET

Despite dreary economic times, a favorable exchange rate beckons foreign tourists to the majestic Grand Circle and beyond.

Opinion: Everyone missed signs of change in eastern Europe

Tom Fenton - Worldview - November 14, 2009 16:43 ET

While reporters did not foresee the fall of the Berlin Wall, the on-the-ground reporting was important.

"Damned United" and the tragedy at Leeds

Mark Starr - Sports - November 13, 2009 21:56 ET

A genuine soccer movie tells the story of Brian Clough, the greatest soccer coach in England to never coach the national team.

Opinion: Nigeria proposes reform of oil industry

John Campbell - Worldview - November 12, 2009 15:39 ET

President Yar'Adua puts forward new legislation but it looks unlikely to effectively reform the industry.

Opinion: Stuck in neutral?

Michael Moran - Worldview - November 12, 2009 06:42 ET

Some Europeans who steered clear of the Cold War may be wavering 20 years later.

The European School: a microcosm of EU integration

William Echikson - Worldview - November 11, 2009 19:32 ET

Czech and Slovak students don't dwell on their countries' communist past.

Opinion: How history's first draft got it wrong

Michael Goldfarb - Worldview - November 11, 2009 12:34 ET

The fall of communism in eastern Europe was not, as Francis Fukuyama wrote, "the end of history."

Opinion: Gay rights go global

Peter Tatchell - Worldview - November 11, 2009 09:22 ET

Homophobia still rules much of the world, but gay people are winning gains in nearly every country.

How 'bout them apples?

C.M. Sennott - Worldview - November 11, 2009 08:24 ET

The U.S. can't compete with China's cheap labor costs and mega orchards in the global apple trade.

Opinion: How consumer choices can drive environmental change

Stephan Faris - Global Green - November 10, 2009 11:38 ET

When businesses realize that eco-friendly alternatives will help their bottom line, they take action.

Opinion: Incorporating lessons from Iraq

Mort Rosenblum - Worldview - November 10, 2009 06:55 ET

Rather than destroying a country in order to save it, turn to the hard slog of nation-building.

Opinion: The day after the Wall fell

Michael Moran - Worldview - November 9, 2009 17:55 ET

The fears of Germany and its neighbors in 1989 have largely been resolved by 2009.

Opinion: ALS, Lou Gehrig and Michael

Mark Starr - Worldview - November 8, 2009 10:16 ET

How one man's struggle with ALS called on Major League Baseball to take a stand.

Opinion: "Old fox" Mugabe outwits others

Douglas Rogers - Worldview - November 8, 2009 09:56 ET

Power-sharing government achieves some improvements but Mugabe still rules with iron fist.

Opinion: Why sanctions aren't the answer for Iran

Joel Brinkley - Worldview - November 6, 2009 15:45 ET

America needs to understand that punitive measures aren't going to keep Iran in check. Not when Russia and China have a lot to lose.