Connect to share and comment

India, explained

TomJoad: Lies, damn lies, and counting the poor

A clear argument for not counting the poor to begin with.

In the wake of the Indian Planning Commission's dubious move to manufacture a 7 percentage point drop in the number of people living below the poverty line by changing its definition of poverty, Shivam Vij makes a convincing case for scrapping the exercise of counting the poor altogether.

"Counting the poor leads us to ask, what about the only -slightly-better-than-the-poor?" Vij writes for "Counting the poor leads us to compare poverty numbers and give us relief. Ah, only 30% Indian poor now, as opposed to 50% in such and such decade, nice! Great job India! No, this is not what the poor deserve, whether they are 30% or 50%. Perhaps we should stop counting the poor."

There are, after all, many other handy ways to keep track.

"Here’s a better benchmark of poverty figures, if we really need them. The mobile phone is today a necessity and when you travel in rural India you realise only the very poor don’t have a mobile phone." So since the latest Census says that 37 percent of India's don't have access to this necessity, "you could say nearly 37% Indian households are poor, not 30%, as the Planning Commission would have us believe."

On the other hand, the same Census informs us that "53.1% households do not have a toilet – for the simple reason that it costs much more to build a toilet than to buy a mobile phone," Vij goes on to point out. "For those among them who can afford a phone, what use being thought of as non-poor?"

The reason for the counting, as I pointed out earlier, of course, is that the counting defines the spending -- especially on the upcoming food subsidy bill. But maybe we should think a little harder about what Vij is saying, anyway. After all, the brilliance of the National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme was that it allowed the poor to self-select: Nobody who didn't need the work would turn up for 100 days of manual labor.

Perhaps there's a way to make other subsidies work the same way.


Featured Slideshow

Rio lagoon filled with 65 tons of dead fish

Heavy rains in Rio de Janeiro caused an ecological nightmare at the lagoon where Olympic rowing will take place in 2016, when 65 tons of dead fish were discovered earlier this week.