Connect to share and comment

A blog about human rights in their many forms.

Israel's free speech problem

Gunter Grass was recently banned from Israel for a poem, but the incident is just another example in a long string of anti-speech actions.
Guntergrass rights 4102012Enlarge
German Nobel literature laureate Gunter Grass poses with his poem for a photo at his house in the northern German town of Behlendorf on April 5, 2012. Grass hit back at what he called a 'campaign' by critics of his poem accusing Israel of plotting Iran's annihilation and threatening world peace. The 84-year-old sparked outrage at home and abroad last Wednesday when he published 'What must be said' in a newspaper in which he said he feared a nuclear-armed Israel 'could wipe out the Iranian people' with a 'first strike'. (MARCUS BRANDT/AFP/Getty Images)

Earlier this week, German writer Gunter Grass was barred from Israel for the content of his poem "What Must Be Said," a meditation on the situation between Israel and Iran. The Nobel laureate's piece, which warns of Israel's military might and condemns German arms sales to Israel caused an outrage in both countries and tempers have flared all over the internet, both in favor of and against the content of the poem.

“Grass’s poems fan the flames of hatred against Israel and the Israeli people, thus promoting the idea he was part of when he donned an SS uniform,” said Israel's interior minister, Eli Yishai, according to the New York Times, apparently referring to the writer's adolescence with the Hitler Youth, an admission Grass made in 2006.

But do words warrant instituting a ban on a person?

More from GlobalPost: Israel bans German writer Gunter Grass from entering country

Grass' controversial past could explain away Israel's actions against that German writer in particular. But it isn't just the poem. Israel has a free speech problem.

In 2010 renowned professor and linguist Noam Chomsky was banned from entry to Israel after an attempt to give a lecture at Bir Zeit University in Ramallah. Norman Finkelstein, also a Jewish professor, was arrested, deported, and banned from Israel for 10 years in 2008. [Here's a slideshow of more controversial critics of Israel who have been banned from entering the country.]

"The decision to prevent someone from voicing their opinions by arresting and deporting them is typical of a totalitarian regime," said Oded Peler, a lawyer for Israel's Association for Civil Rights to the Guardian after Finkelstein's deportation. "A democratic state, where freedom of expression is the highest principle, does not shut out criticism or ideas just because they are uncomfortable for its authorities to hear. It confronts those ideas in public debate."

In Israel, there is no protection of freedom of speech, because there is no constitution. There is no specific legal accountability in regard to words or art, because no Israeli document exists that protects this inalienable human right, the way the US Constitution does. The Knesset makes laws and the Supreme Court decides if they're legal or not, but there is nothing equal to a universal free speech provision on the books in Israel. 

More from GlobalPost: Israel breaks with UN Human Rights Council over settlement inquiry

In the past few years, it has become apparent that without a central document that protects freedoms, the Knesset has the ability to pass laws without being accountable to a higher idea of human rights. Besides a recent law against organizing boycotts of Israeli goods, which one Israeli journalist called "fascism at its worst," there have been a flood of incidents that would never fly in the face in of the American First Amendment — or even the most general understanding of the concept of free speech. 

"Israelis accept limits on free expression that other democracies would reject," explained Edmund Sanders in a July Los Angeles Times article. "...many of the controversial measures received solid public support, reflecting a growing ambivalence in Israel over free-speech rights."

The Israeli government also insists that some news outlets submit their reports for approval before publication. A Palestinian TV station was recently shut down without cause or warning, and, according Human Rights Watch, hundreds of thousands of dollars of equipment was seized. Journalists are routinely detained and questioned, and a professor was recently arrested for launching a new website through Al Quds University. 

"Unfortunately for Israelis, their country has anti-free speech policies that do not represent modern democracy. Israel is more open than countries it borders, yes, but this isn’t a liberating revelation," wrote blogger Justin Martin at the Columbia Journalism Review. "If Israeli politicians wish to brag that their nation resembles western democracies, they must defend the freedoms those countries hold dear. Israel does not."

The full text of "What Must Be Said" can be found at The Atlantic

http://www.globalpost.com/dispatches/globalpost-blogs/rights/israels-slippery-slope-censorship

.

Featured Slideshow

Rio lagoon filled with 65 tons of dead fish

Heavy rains in Rio de Janeiro caused an ecological nightmare at the lagoon where Olympic rowing will take place in 2016, when 65 tons of dead fish were discovered earlier this week.