Connect to share and comment

A guide to the dynamic economics, politics, and culture of the world's most populous region.

Indonesia's Aceh defends public caning

Amnesty International condemns the Qur'an-based punishment. Clerics say critics just don't get it.
Caning aceh amnesty 2011 05 23Enlarge
A man arrested for gambling is struck with a cane six times by an executioner during a public caning at the compound of a mosque in Aceh Besar on January 29, 2010. The man was arrested for gambling while his three companions escaped. Aceh province has a special autonomy and it has defined itself as apart from the rest of Indonesia by implementing Shariah law and creating a religious police. (CHAIDEER MAHYUDDIN/AFP/Getty Images)

Boozers and gamblers in Indonesia's most fundamentalist province are sometimes punished with more than a hangover and empty pockets.

Offenders risk painful whacks with a rattan cane. And the whole town is invited to watch.

Aceh province, allowed to operate under Qur'an-based Shariah law, says caning is Islam's favored punishment for pre-martial coupling, drinking, gambling and a number of other light crimes.

But Amnesty International says the canings can "constitute cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment and often amount to torture.” According to the human rights group, Aceh authorities have set off on a caning spree, lashing 21 people in recent weeks while only lashing 16 people all of last year.

Furthermore, Amnesty insists caning violates U.N. conventions against torture, which Indonesia signed more than 10 years ago.

Provincial clerics' response? Amnesty just doesn't get Islam. And it selectively picks on Muslim-majority Aceh instead of Singapore, which also practices caning, or abuses committed by Israel or France against Muslims.

Besides, one scholar told the Jakarta Globe, the punishment is only applied to Muslims.

"It is their right to criticize," he told the Globe, "but as long as they do not seek to understand Shariah, they will continue to criticize something they know little about.”

http://www.globalpost.com/dispatches/globalpost-blogs/the-rice-bowl/indonesias-aceh-defends-public-caning