Connect to share and comment

No, Greeks are not giving themselves HIV to get welfare

An ill-written paragraph in a report by the World Health Organization seemed to make the claim that half of all new HIV infections in Greece were self-inflicted to get $950 a month in welfare.
greece HIV correctionEnlarge
Drug addicts are pictured in central Athens in this undated photo. The WHO confirmed Tuesday that Greeks are not infecting themselves with HIV using intravenous drugs in large numbers to collect welfare benefits. (Iakovos Chatzistavrou/AFP/Getty Images)

No, Greeks are not giving themselves HIV to get welfare benefits during a time of severe austerity, the World Health Organization (WHO) confirmed Tuesday.

Reports circulated in the media, in outlets such as Fox News, the Daily Caller, Sky News, and Al Jazeera, that Greeks were deliberately infecting themselves with the virus to be eligible for a government handout of 700 euros a month (around $950).

They sourced an ill-written paragraph in a report by the United Nations' health agency from Oct. 30 that seemed to make the claim that half of all new HIV infections were self-inflicted.

The paragraph read: "HIV rates and heroin use have risen significantly, with about half of new HIV infections being self-inflicted to enable people to receive benefits of 700 euros per month and faster admission on to drug substitution programmes."

This is not true, either way you read it. Neither are half of the new HIV infections in Greece self-inflicted, nor are half of the new infections among drug users self-inflicted.

When asked by GlobalPost, the author of a report cited by the WHO in their case study said that the figure was incorrect:

The WHO apologized for the error on Tuesday and issued a correction.

In a statement they wrote: "The sentence should read: "half of the new HIV cases are self-injecting and out of them few are deliberately inflicting the virus". The statement is the consequence of an error in the editing of the document, for which WHO apologizes."

"WHO recognizes that there is no evidence suggesting that deliberate self-infection with HIV goes beyond a few anecdotal cases," WHO said.

The original WHO report was created by the Institute of Health Equity at University College London.

Before the correction, the media wrote blaring headlines claiming that Greeks had infected themselves with HIV to get welfare.

Here's an example:

The watchdog website Media Matters was quick to criticize the claims, particularly by right-wing pundit Rush Limbaugh, who claimed on his radio program that the report showed the flaws of the welfare system

http://www.globalpost.com/dispatches/globalpost-blogs/weird-wide-web/no-greeks-are-not-giving-themselves-hiv-get-welfare

.

Featured Slideshow

The 2013 World Press Photo Awards

Culled from more than 100,000 submissions, these photos represent the best in photojournalism from the past year.